| Family
Thoughts. We recently finished our Family Weekend in the
Country Dacha Ritual. That means 16 of us in a 5 bedroom cottage getting
through a weekend which was the product of intense negotiation that somehow
we will forget within 6 months and then consider doing again next year.
We had a maid come in daily to clean up but you’d never believe it. I went
horseback riding and everyone made fun of my blue Italian pants which I
considered jeans. Anyway, they stretched well with the gallop and helped
my butt ache less afterward. So we all screamed at each other around the
dining room table and argued into the night. I called one of my Ph.D. relatives
a moron and he actually took it personally. The arguments ranged from the
profound (“You voted for Gore; you were Stupid!”) to the arcane – One person
says “You don’t Understand.” Then the other person says “You don’t
Understand.” Then my brother points at both of them and mocking-dramatically
says “You don’t Understand.”....and this can keep up for about 20 minutes.
One of the in-laws was the Phantom of the Opera, hiding in the basement
for virtually the entire weekend. Maybe she knows something we don’t. She
came up during one of these arguments and I said to her “Are you really
sure you want to be here for this?” Obviously these are the enchanting
reasons she married into this family. By the time we were driving toward
the highway and we passed the site of my parents’ honeymoon, she said “I
don’t want to ever see that place. I don’t want to ever see this part of
the planet again for the rest of my life.” I guess you just had to be there....
Anyway, I had a good time and my little nephews and nieces, who aren’t
into all the politics and game-playing, had lots of fun which is the reason
we were all there anyway. Where else do you get to be a hero for killing
the big spider in the little girls’ room that’s freaking them out? Here
you have to be happy when you come downstairs and see a 2 year old writing
all over a bedspread with a magic marker. I mean isn’t it great when your
nearly 2-year old nephew finds your camera buried amidst the rubble on
the basement ping-pong table, brings it upstairs, puts in your lap and
says “Cheese.” Compare that to my mom who, upon putting a camera into her
hand to take a picture of me and the kids, says “Is this a camera?”
Most of the gang. Getting everyone together for a picture is Impossible.
Cute photo, eh?
Global Thoughts.
I haven’t written lately because I’d rather not write than write trite.
Much of what is important to know is out there in print, but it is the
synthesis and spin that makes GlobalThoughts unique.
What has changed during the past
year and, indeed, did 9/11/01 represent a change in anything?
Economics. Jobs left downtown
but residents are returning. Economic performance is down because of the
Internet bubble that burst and the wave of corporate scandal that proved
the bubble’s existence across the board. Even Martha Stewart and GE were
popped bubbles. Enron was the country’s 7th largest company, and that was
nothing compared to Worldcom. The biggest economic danger right now is
deflation – prices in some sectors seem to be dropping. Real estate is
overvalued; I have warned about this for awhile. It is the next bubble
to burst.
Security. We are beginning
to realize how naked we are, securitywise. We are more alert and catching
more suspicious things. The problem with airport security is that we are
finding electric shavers inside passenger baggage but not things that people
want to hide. And someone with 10 syringes claiming they are filled with
insulin will get through without question but someone with nail clippers
will get frisked and have his goods confiscated. It is more stupid than
safe because we are still screening things according to lists, not people
based on intuition. Because the determined terrorist will still win. It
is not very comforting to feel that at least next time we will be caught
because we missed something and not because we weren’t watching. Prediction:
The next terrorist attack on an airplane will not come from a passenger
but from checked luggage. Such a bomb will probably kill the Airbus double-decker
jumbo-jet program.
US Foreign Policy. We still
prefer to react to crisis than invest in the future to avoid crisis. We
are doing only the minimum in Afghanistan and the world sees a puppet running
the city-state of Kabul and knows he wouldn’t last through lunch without
his contingent of American bodyguards. The picture fills leaders of nations
with a lack of confidence that America will know what to do after it tears
Iraq apart.
American Moslems. It was inevitable
that racial profiling would begin and that non-Moslem Americans would become
suspicious of all Moslems as it became clear that supporters of Al-Qaeda
were hiding within Moslem communities inside America. A year ago I immediately
suggested that the amount of the fear would be inversely proportional to
the extent that the Moslem community took the lead in exposing these people
and condemning their actions. Americans feel that Moslem and community
leaders, both in Saudi Arabia and inside America, missed the opportunity
to get in front of the issue quickly and are paying the inevitable price.
Regardless of the logic involved, the result will be that Moslems in America
will become more insular like their counterparts in Europe and the danger
to America from alienated Moslems inside America will increase. Remember
that half of the 19 hijackers were alienated Moslems living in Europe that
were radicalized in Europe (the rest were Moslems from Arab countries)
that came to America and did most of the creative work that led to 9/11.
Bush. I always
joke with customs agents when they see me carrying my own pillow: “The
Leader of the Free World also carries his own pillow.” Bush, they say,
is not so smart. Well, I answer, maybe that isn’t such a good example.
If you’ve noticed, Bush always has a sign up next to his podium telling
you some kind of message of the day to put a one-liner behind the subject
of the news conference. He recently had a press conference standing in
front of Mount Rushmore and actually had a poster of Mount Rushmore behind
his podium right in front of Mount Rushmore. Sometimes, you just wonder,
like duh? I’m just waiting for the press conference that features him in
front of a huge poster that says “Press Conference” with a picture of a
lectern on it.
Pakstian / India. There
is a big story going on here. US planes are being shot at more on the Pakistani
side of the border than is known. The Pakistani side of the border is housing
many hostile elements that are not being controlled by the Pakistani government.
I think Musharaf is making a mistake by not letting any democracy in his
country and making this month's coming elections a farce; if there would
be a real vote, the extremists wouldn’t poll 10% and would be discredited.
Instead, they will loom larger than life, feed on whatever discontent exists,
and eventually kill him. There will be elections this month in Kashmir
and hopefully it will lead to peacetalks afterward. The Indians realized
this past summer that saber rattling with regard to Kashmir was endangering
any foreign investment in their IT sector because companies didn’t want
to be associated with an increasingly unstable region on the verge of a
nuclear war and were threatening to pull out of the country. There will
be a good chance this year to settle the Kashmir conflict if Musharaf doesn’t
insist on playing games with Kashmir in order to keep his extremists at
bay – in other words, if Musharaf doesn’t act like Arafat with Hamas.
IRAQ – No doubt in my mind
that the US will act forcefully sometime during the next few months, but
not before the end of November. I’m not going to try and figure out its
military strategy. I assume the Israelis and the Iranians will try to make
as little trouble as possible for a while so as not to disrupt the US mission.
The best strategy goes for the head of the snake and leaves the physical
assets of the country intact. Because Saddam keeps much of his army outside
Baghdad because he is afraid of a coup, this actually makes the job easier.
Regime change in Iraq holds the following possibilities: (1) A more friendly
Iraq will produce lots of oil, decrease Saudi market share and help stabilize
the market in the long run, despite any short-term price spike. (2) A more
democratic Iraq (and the pressure on Saudi Arabia as a result of (1)) will
accelerate change throughout the Arab world. It may prevent Saudi Arabia
from turning into a fundamentalist country, which is what I think will
happen if the status quo is allowed to continue. Prediction: Saudi Arabia
will be under a different sort of government within 5 years; either solidly
within the pro-West camp or fundamentalist, but not under the monarchy
it has now. (3) The pace of change in Iran will quicken. (4) The Palestinians
will lose a major source of financial backing for extremist resistance
which has in large part hijacked moderates from pushing leadership toward
progress. (5) Syria will not want to be isolated without having gained
anything in the transaction and will seek to become more integrated into
the region.
Life sucks right now in the Middle
East. People know that what they are doing right now is not working for
the long term, even if it makes them feel somewhat OK for today. An internationally
famous rabbi I sit next to in synagogue who goes around making speeches
about how great Israel is tells me privately that he just returned from
Israel and is depressed because people in Israel see no future. He himself
said he wouldn’t move there right now, no way. My main argument for action
is that things in the region are so screwed up that only some kind of Big
Bang will shake things up and force real change throughout the region,
including the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The powers that be want things
to stay the same and they profit from this mess. It’s good for them; it
allows them to do nothing and promises nothing for Real People. Maybe change
will not be good; but I think that over the next 5 years, there will be
many more beneficiaries than victims in Iraq if the US goes in and gets
rid of Saddam. That’s been the case in Afghanistan where a few lives were
lost, but many more saved and improved.
This doesn’t mean that the US will
manage regime change well and bring about any of the above scenarios. There
will be no progress as to item 4 if the Palestinians are still facing Sharon
or Bibi leading the Israelis. But these are possibilities and I absolutely
believe that within 6 months of some moderate leading the Palestinians,
the Israelis will change leaders and perhaps the next leader won’t be a
former general but someone who represents the aspirations of Normal Society.
One thing is certain: Keeping the status quo in the region will only ensure
the threat of nuclear blackmail by a powerful neighborhood bully either
directly or via a leak to a friendly ally, nuclear buildup by everyone
else who will be afraid to do otherwise, a certain security for parochial
self-serving monarchies that have no interest in bringing about progress,
and keeping alive the main source of funding that permits extremists and
governments to hijack the Palestinian issue to divert attention away from
anything else for everyone in the region.
Should the US act unilaterally? The
UN has been ignored by Iraq for the past decade. Several countries on the
security council have tried to play both ends of the game with Iraq. At
the end of the day, more than half the US Dollars in circulation in the
world are held outside the US. 9/11 reminded the world that rogues
with bombs and hostile intent are a danger to the US and to everyone else
because we all rely on the stability of the American system. In the years
leading up to World War II, there were similar cautions by mulilateralists
and isolationists, each for their own reasons, but it was American action
in a war that had no reason to involve them until they were attacked that
was ultimately necessary to bring about a new generation of renewal in
Europe and Asia. France and Russia can debate all they want, but they cannot
accomplish change in the Middle East or anywhere else. They can cause trouble,
but they have more to gain over the long haul by cooperating. I think both
countries get the point now and the changes in France, Denmark and Italy
have been noticeable. I expect Germany will get with the program after
their elections.
A few thoughts about what people
think they know: It is important to realize how much money Iraq is spending
in the region paying off journalists and government officials. Ministers
in Jordan are receiving new Mercedes cars paid by Iraq; journalists are
being given huge bribes to guarantee favorable press coverage. This is
documented stuff; not fluffy allegations. We know the Saudis paid Al Qaeda
$300 million a number of years ago to promise not to bomb Saudi targets.
Remember that money makes things go round in this region. It’s not something
we read about in the newspapers. You won’t read these facts in those Arab
newspapers which are not free and where payola dictates what gets printed.
That doesn’t mean I don’t care about what’s in the Arab press. But realize
that agendas are at work here. And as long as people as high as Saudia’s
Abdullah are relying on such media to get his information about what is
going on here (see detail later) and actively permit their media to be
used as propaganda to divert attention from real news and debate about
real issues, something will always be out of sync.
I know of a family in Pakistan whose
kids heard in their Madrassah that on 9/11 4,000 Jews didn’t go to work
in the World Trade Center because they were told not to come. This rumor
has been making the rounds all over the Middle East during the past year
and I suppose that as many Moslems believe it is true as Blacks in Los
Angeles still believe that OJ Simpson is innocent of murdering his wife.
The parents explained to their kids that this was ridiculous. Some omnipotent
organization would have had to gather such a list of Jews (Jews themselves
can hardly come up with such lists in today’s American assimiliated society),
call up 4,000 people spread across hundreds of companies in these buildings,
make all these calls in one night without anyone raising any suspicions
to tell anyone else, and then afterward no one can name a single person
who was told not to go to work that day. The kids raised the point in school
the next day. The parents were called by the Madrassah and told to stop
challenging the propaganda or that their kids would be ostracized.
What does this mean in the context
of 9/11?
America looks at this, asks why Moslems
hate us and figures it's all about propaganda and that the solution is
to start selling US Foreign Policy the same way we sell Big Macs. No wonder
we haven’t made any friends in the region this past year and instead have
created even more resentment and instability, especially with all this
talk of unilateral action.
9/11 was a result of America’s failure
to engage the rest of the world in a full way. America engaged the world
partially (ie: comes in and busts up a place and then withdraws leaving
people to their own devices which leads to chaos), and was resented for
it. America was faulted for cheerleading values but applying them selectively
with double standards. It is not that America tried to avoid the world
and the world came to it or that America was too involved in the world
and the world struck back. It was the backlash of an inconsistent policy
that came back to haunt America. That is my assessment as to why 9/11 happened.
What follows is that America is wasting
its money and effort trying to comb every last sand dune in Afghanistan
and Pakistan hunting for Taliban. To listen to our generals speaking to
the troops in Afghanistan put it, "You boys are there to kill Taliban."
We are not going to find many Taliban and I hear the Afghans are starting
to throw rocks instead of rice at our special forces guys in the hinterlands;
we are overstaying our welcome if we are only going to have a peace force
in Kabul and hunt Taliban everywhere else. We should expand the peacekeeping
force in Afghanistan because that aspect of the operation has popular support.
Beyond that, we would be much better off (and it would be much cheaper)
funding schools in these and other countries and improving the lives of
people so that they wouldn’t want to shelter and support these people.
That Saudi or Iranian funded Madrassah in Pakistan wouldn’t be there had
the US put money into Pakistan education instead of abandoning the country
during the 80's leaving them with an education system in tatters. Forget
about PR – focus on the policy itself. Our policy needs to be more dynamic.
The Bush Administration is filled with cold-warriers left over from the
Reagan years who know the world has changed but are still clueless to deal
with it. The Democrats don’t have any ideas either; they will run simply
on the idea that the economy has soured since the Republicans took over
(a fact which isn’t true but which will sell well in the coming elections).
We’re not that bad and the people
judging us are not perfect either. Remember how all the Arabs warned against
change in Afghanistan. When the Taliban were thrown out, the people partied
and it became open season against the Arabs who in fact were the foreigners
screwing up Afghanistan. We could do better but at least you know that
when you see American soldiers sitting in Afghanistan, you see Blacks,
Whites, Women, Hispanics, Asians, etc. (Think of that Taliban dude being
guarded by a blond soldier holding a machine gun. Our women drive helicopters,
not just cars.) They are keeping the peace in an area where the various
factions who live there can’t figure out on their own how to get along.
We have a society in which people get along. Democracy and religious pluralism
is a messy system, but it still works better than the other systems. Don’t
knock it till you’ve tried it. Our challenge ought to be to help people
realize democracy and not excuse the lack of it because some dictator we
are aligned with says that his people aren’t suitable for democracy. I
think that over the past year America has become more sensitive in this
regard; the governments of Egypt and Saudi Arabia are getting the cold
shoulder from us because of it. This may ultimately work to the benefit
of the people of Egypt and Saudi Arabia. I have written angry words about
the government and condition of Saudi Arabia this year but I have not meant
to offend the people of Saudi Arabia. Instead of getting angry at
each other, we ought to be talking more because, on a personal level, we
do want the people of these countries to succeed and be our friends, not
just because it is conducive to security and economy, but because we are
all good people who share common values, university, enjoy the same DVD’s,
fast food and Disney World, love our families, and we should remain friends.
I just bought several copies of a
photograph that appeared from the AP in mid-August, one for myself, one
to send to the family of an officer who served in Afghanistan, and one
to hang in my niece’s bedroom. The picture shows a little Afghan girl catching
a softball and she is doing so with great determination in her eyes. She
is the only girl with a catcher’s mitt and she has now been allowed to
practice on the sidelines of the boy’s team; a girl’s team is soon to be
formed. This is inspiring to me; it is the side of America and humanity
I want to believe in, even if it is somewhat romantic. It means that anyone
can be what they want to be, and that America is a force in the world to
help people be all they can be. We are not perfect in our actions, but
it is an ideal we all share in our hearts which is why the bottom line
is that the people of the world do like Americans.
ISRAEL/PALESTINIAN AFFAIRS
America hardly understands Israel
or Arabs, but right now is not acting as a broker in the region; this administration
has sided with Israel. It is a strange breed of people that have joined
hands that have come to dominate this administration. There were more Jews
in Clinton’s administration and the Clinton administration was more balanced
with regard to the Israel-Palestinian issue; in this case, you have Christian
evangelicals who show up to Jewish rallies for Israel and say things the
Jews wouldn’t dare say out loud. That is not in America’s long term interest
because Israel is not America, and the Jews will ultimately pay a price
for this temporary imbalance because it is not natural although it is providing
a temporary benefit. But these close ties are necessary right now because
close coordination is useful toward getting rid of Saddam. Because the
Arabs are supposedly not going to be part of an anti-Saddam coalition,
it actually makes it easier for the Americans and Israelis to coordinate.
But really – don’t believe everything you hear. When the Americans hit
Iraq a few weeks ago, the Saudis provided the air cover even though publicly
all the talk is that of non-cooperation. When push comes to shove and the
end game is in sight, everyone in the region will get behind the American
program and I assume the Israelis will stay out unless they have to get
involved; why take the risk of landing a punch when Big Daddy has come
to the playground to get rid of the bully.
The root of the existing problem
here is that Bush, Sharon, Barak and Yaalon (the new chief of staff who
seems to be rather robotic) all seek to REACT to the Palestinian issue,
not SOLVE it. The debate in Israel today is between those who view Palestinians
as a Cancer that is incurable or a Virus that can be vaccinated against.
A disease carries no legitimacy. If the Palestinian issue will be viewed
solely as a disease and not as a competing interest that requires engagement,
compromise and accommodation, it can never be solved. This is a psychological
thing and Israelis both on the Left and Right have yet to get over this
hurdle. Even the bleeding-heart Left insists on imposing solutions because
“they know better what is good for them.” The Arabs find this patronizing
and are not sure they can deal with such people any better than the Right-wing
fanatic who at least makes no effort to camouflage his attitude of superior
hostility and determination not to budge. This arena will simmer for awhile
while Palestinians work out their affairs and decide who represents them
when the deck of cards in the region is reshuffled and they determine what
they want to achieve and where they stand in the scheme of things. No doubt
they are in the process of re-examining old assumptions and making adjustments.
More than anything, they are in the process of figuring out what they truly
want, something the Oslo process didn’t force them to come to grips with.
I believe Dahlan who says that the dance of death is coming toward the
end; the last 2 years was a waste but it was part of the shakeout that
was inevitable. Progress is being made here and I am optimistic. The Israelis
are realizing Jerusalem is not a united city; the Palestinians are realizing
they can't talk about the right of return to pre-1948 Israel, and the world
is just bored with the whole conflict and so neither side can get any attention
or sympathy from outside unless they face each other and get down to business.
Yes, it can get better than this.
STATE OF THE WORLD
A disturbing trend – the world is
more interconnected with regard to information via the Internet and satellite
television than ever before, but people are tuning into the versions of
the truth they want most to believe and this is leading to less understanding
than ever before. Someone met this year with Saudi Crown Prince Abdullah
who doesn’t speak English and who holds court in a big room with 20 TV
screens tuned to all the Arab satellite TV stations for his news about
the region. The view of the region from Al-Jazeerah is quite different
from that of the BBC or CNN or even ANN (Arab News Network). This person
wound up having a long talk with Abdullah and was amazed at things Abdullah
didn’t know. I personally know this kind of thing is true, because I have
visited places where people don’t get their news from anything beyond local
official sources and are completely ignorant about certain things. By the
way, this is true among Jews in America who only want to view the Middle
East via their favorite website. Right now it is in fashion for Right-wing
Jews to boycott major metropolitan newspapers as "anti-semitic." No matter
that half the writers and editors are Jewish. I have met important
leaders of major organizations who say they don’t read the New York Times
or the Economist because it’s “anti-Semitic.” It has become a bit nutty.
My personal view is that I read anything with news that is reliable, whether
or not I agree with the political point of view. I wrote about this disturbing
phenomenon in Global Thoughts: Musings / Media Bias 20 January 2001.
Some good books I'm reading: Tom
Friedman's Longititudes and Attitudes, a collection of recent columns and
diary of things that inspired those columns. I really think he gets it.
Another book: What Went Wrong by Bernard Lewis, reknown Middle East historian.
Tonight is Yom Kippur, the Jewish
Day of Atonement. It is a time of repentance, charity, prayer and fasting,
much like Ramadan for those who take it seriously. I pray not only for
the peace of my family and the House of Israel, but for all of the people
in the world – not only in the abstract, but for the people who I know
personally and their families. It is believed that on Yom Kippur God seals
the fate of all mankind, not just the Jews. It is a time to take stock
of where one is in his or her life and to look at the broader scheme of
things in the world.
Last week during Rosh Hashana (the
New Year), the Bible reading is, as it is every year, the chapter from
Genesis about the Sacrifice of Isaac. It takes on a special meaning this
year because Abraham wanted to sacrifice his son but the angel of God pulled
him back saying in 22:12 “Do not stretch out your hand against the lad
nor do anything to him for now I know that you are a God fearing man, since
you have not withheld your son, your only one, from Me.” You could read
this two ways: (1) Child sacrifice is good because the fact that Abraham
was willing to do it showed his perfect faith. (2) Child sacrifice is not
good because God told him that the willingness to do it was worth more
than the actual doing of it. I think that the conventional interpretation
is the second one. I don’t know how Moslems extremists read this, but I
suppose that moderate Moslems also follow the second interpretation. Notice
that, in any event, there is nothing here about someone committing suicide
as part of a jihad against someone else; it is an isolated incident based
solely on the attestation of faith to God in an allegorical sense, especially
since God puts a stop to the activity which he himself had proposed.
There is another story involving
Abraham which is instructive to Global Thoughts and which I think also
takes on particular meaning this year. Abraham beholds the city of Sodom
and Gemorah, defined as Ultimate Evil in his day. He yet begs God to save
the city if he can even find 50 good men, or 40, 30, 20, 10 or even just
one. Having found not one, God destroys the city. It is a lesson that sometimes
Evil exists and must be eradicated and that the result is inescapable,
despite Koffi Annan or Abraham’s protests to the contrary.
We live in a world today where 9/11
forced a sleeping giant and the rest of mankind to confront the manifestation
of an evil act that few could have imagined. It has forced us all to change
something in our lives because we are being forced to imagine all kinds
of possible evil things that could happen. It brings out the darker side
of good people, because people are now suspicious of each other, prejudices
find some justification in reality, and because evildoers are willing to
take advantage of the weakness of our better nature to do things that we
believe are beyond the pale of civilized people. It forces divisions and
makes people want to retreat into their tree houses and avoid engaging
others. “Who needs them; we can live without them; we should have known
all along that they are no good” are the common refrains on all sides.
If we shall do this, we shall give
Bin Laden his ultimate victory. He wants Moslems in America and all over
to be ostracized and forced by the rest of the world to retreat into their
own world and he wants everyone in the world to sit home or in a mosque
reading the Koran, hate anyone remotely different than himself, and die.
This one sentence to me sums up his whole ideology. It is a flash in the
pan for anyone who takes him up on it -- a promise of eternal glory in
a world we don’t live to experience and do not know exists, but there can
be no future in this world we do know exists in death, stagnation, hate
and isolation. I think the cult of martyrdom has hit its peak in Palestine;
the people are too educated to go on for too long believing that the past
two years has done anything for their cause besides turning back the clock
15 years and bringing Sharon to power. The Iranian youth want their futures
back; only the Saudis are so alienated that they are on the verge of first
tasting the fruits of Islamic fundamentalist revolution before they realize
it is fruit from the Tree of Knowledge – it will make them realize the
nakedness of their idealized society in the face of the rest of the world’s
presence and progress. Think back about Adam and Eve; they ate the apple
which was to make them know the Meaning of Life and then realized their
nakedness and then found they couldn’t hide from God. What does it mean
to us today?
These stories mean something today.
They mean that we can’t retreat to our tree-houses post 9/11 and say we
are angry, no one understands us and it would be better to avoid the rest
of the world. Rather, we must stay engaged and keep the lines open. The
Internet is useful to an extent but it also lies, just as we have learned
over the years that the camera lies. Real information exchange still comes
face-to-face, mano-a-mano, and we must allow for a world with shades of
grey and seek solutions that are adequate if not entirely just and perfect
instead of waiting for all the cosmos to be in perfect alignment before
we do anything. You cannot substitute the efficiency of technology for
the warmth of humanity, either in terms of intelligence gathering, security
screening, or just plain understanding what people are thinking and intending.
There is no Tree of Knowledge that contains all the simple answers to our
complex world in one fruit. Try to imagine you can eat that fruit and know
all, and you will only come to realize how much you truly don’t know. The
fundamentalist doesn’t believe – he is sure that he Knows. Therein lies
the crux of the matter. He cannot live with contradiction on such heavy
issues; better to die by it.
I am not against Islam; a modern
political state based on Islamic principles would be an important addition
to the world. The Jews still haven’t figured out how to combine religion
and politics in Israel; the West is religiously secular and anyone who
travels in the region realizes that secular Moslems are more religious
than secular Christians or Jews. I was hoping that Pakistan might figure
out a balance, but Musharraf is not looking for balance. But look in India,
Indonesia and Malaysia and you can see that democracies with Moslem majorities
can work; there are conflicts in these countries, but they are resolved
in conventional ways.
One more Yom Kippur thought. At the
height of the fast when we feel weak, pure and righteous, we sit for half
an hour every year and read aloud the story of Jonah (you know, Jonah and
the Whale). He wanted God to destroy the nation of Nineveh that he thought
was evil. Jonah wound up inside the whale as a punishment because he was
more interested in imposing his version of heavenly justice than in trying
to cope with humanity. He ultimately was so angry that he was willing to
die and let God destroy the vine of shade that had grown around his treehouse
to shield him from the burning sun. It is clear from the text that God
didn't approve of his self-righteous attitude, either in wanting Nineveh
to be destroyed, or even for him to enjoy the vine and then let God destroy
that too. Jonah was sort a fundamentalist of his time, and the kind we
see today who values death over life. The point of the story is that there
was good and evil in his day as is ours, but neither God nor Man must want
destruction of mankind or for even his designated prophet to be excessively
self-righteous about it. We are not supposed to be running around feeling
superior to others and trying to impose on them; we are supposed to figure
out how to get along and keep the peace. God wants us to work these things
out on Earth among ourselves. Anyone who thinks he knows better will have
to contend with God, be he thrown over a ship into the seas and the waiting
whale, or be he in a cave in Afghanistan. Fundamentalists of all stripes
and religions beware.
Now is a time of great decision.
America will do things in the world that will affect your life, no matter
where you sit. Even in Switzerland, a bad NASDAQ day ruins your day and
a plane hitting the World Trade Center could set you back for months because
we’re all in this economy together. That’s what my Swiss friend told me
last time I visited Zurich. I haven’t been out enough talking to people
this past year and, while the passage of time permits people to cool off
and gather context, it is past due to make the rounds. So on this anniversary
of 9/11, I am planning a new journey to visit my amigos in Europe and the
Middle East to listen to what they have to say about the state of the world,
share ideas, and ultimately report back to you what it means to me. This
past year I haven’t gotten a whole lot of mail from the Middle East and
I feel a bit in a vacuum trying to figure out what Real People have to
say about it. The last time I felt this way was the summer of 2000 and
I failed to properly anticipate the buildup that led to the Al-Aksa Intifada
that September. So it is best to make the rounds and keep current.
Whether or not I see 50, 40, 30,
10 or even 1 person, and whether or not it is 50, 40 or 10 people who read
Global Thoughts, if we are out there contributing on a personal level to
increase the level of understanding among our colleagues that are blessed
with the ability to communicate and travel across national borders, it
is a small dose of balance toward peace injected into the world that makes
life a bit more worthwhile and meaningful beyond one’s self and the work
he does for his daily bread. It is motivation and justification to keep
moving forward. I hope those reading this feel similarly.
I sometimes feel that we don’t get
what we pray for because we don’t really know what we truly want. I wish
everyone this year that when they figure out what they really want, they
will get it.
A pier in Pointe au Pic, Quebec
on a foggy Sunday morning. Right now I am listening to a song that says
"All the world is a narrow bridge; the essential thing is to cross it without
fear."
|