| Thursday
August 28, 1997....To JFK during rush hour, best to get off the highway
and use Woodhaven Avenue in Queens a few miles after exiting the Midtown
Tunnel. Made it to the airport in 50 minutes; not easy to get a taxi to
agree to go to Kennedy during rush hour. Taxi is $40. At Delta, we used
gate 14 which was the least distance I ever had to go from curbside to
plane. They x-ray the bag at the entrance to the terminal and it's another
30 steps to the gate and you just show your ticket and board. You could
arrive 15 minutes before a flight with this setup. Delta flies a 767 in
both directions; 8:45 going; 9:15 coming; the passenger count was split
evenly between Americans and Russians and the flights were about 2/3 full.
The plane is not bad but tighter than a 747 in the seat and a bit tight
if you have someone sitting next to you (2:3:2 configuration). They spend
a lot of time with cabin service and don't shut out the lights until 3½
hours into the flight. The 6pm flight arrives at 11:30, turns around at
2pm and arrives New York at 4. Upon arrival in both Moscow and NY I was
one of the first off the plane and got through customs in 5 minutes so
I can't tell how it is for the average person. The Moscow airport is still
dark and dreary with the lights turned out but let's be fair -- so was
Zurich on arrival and quite a few departure areas in various airports such
as Frankfurt. Sasha was waiting for me at the exit and it was a 40 minute
ride to city center.
No more swerving to avoid potholes in the streets;
no exhaust being spewed as people restart their cars at traffic lights
as it was 5 years ago; the streets have been repaved; there are Mercedes
and other new cars all over; gas is about 25% more expensive than the USA;
there are colorful banners and flags EVERYWHERE for the 850th
Birthday of Moscow Festival soon to take place; billboards selling everything
imaginable and the streets look orderly and actually grand with the newly
painted and restored building facades lining the streets. Surprise! Moscow
has reinvented itself and has begun to look like a World Capitol!
Friday...Visited Sasha's office with all the modern
conveniences and company cafeteria and set out to the Tretyakov Museum,
recently reopened after a 7 year restoration and looks as impressive inside
and out as any Metropolitan museum in the West. You can rent a walkman
with tours in English. About half the paintings have English (and Russian)
captions. Mix of Russian and European art and the painting of Ivan The
Terrible grieving over his son whom he killed in a fit of fury was of notice.
Actually, the name The Terrible wasn't given to him until long after he
died; while he was alive he was known as the Torturer. I was somewhat out
of it but thought a museum was a good place to try and keep awake.
A walk around the area; the city now passes the
Clean Fingernail test (at the end of the day, the fingernails are reasonably
clean). Parks are well kept up with landscaping and flowers everywhere;
the fountains all work; every lightbulb is lit on the streets and in the
metro; children skate on rollerblades (too many potholes for skating last
visit); people look happy and there are many romantic people in the parks.
The funniest thing I saw was a man in his 60's with a woman 20 years younger
having a fit of passion on a park bench; he was literally attacking her.
By the time I whipped out the camera, they had stopped. Maybe they saw
me. Stopped at a supermarket and cafe; it's even better than the USA now
because you have a choice of the world's best of everything (even weird
items such as unusual types of cream cheese); in the USA you can only choose
from several American brands of particular items. Brush with reality; there
are guards at the entrance wearing black pants and shirts and they are
at the entrances to just about any business involving luxury. I suppose
they want their well heeled patrons to feel safe and are afraid of robbery
or assault as well. Metro stations have been spruced up with more permanent-like
kiosks and pretty glassy-looking overhangs with cute "M" signs. People
are more into appearances; the stores all sell Western hygiene products
and people must be using them or else all these stores couldn't pay rent.
Not that Russians are fashion plates; the elite dress obnoxiously Villagey
or just plain old extravagant without style and the average Boris still
wears thrift shop looking items. The Gap hasn't opened yet but this country
could use a good dose of it. I was clearly the best dressed person on the
street and strangely it didn't appear that people were looking at me. Cosmopolitan
Magazine just published an 850 page issue in Russian for the festival and
people are buying it. All the stores that used to sell Russian products
now sell only Western products; it's as if all the Russian stuff has disappeared.
The prices are comparable to the US and maybe a bit more on some items
and a bit less on others. I don't know how people can afford them on their
salaries but these stores are all over even in the residential neighborhoods
such as the one I stayed in and are obviously still open.
After the walkabout, we picked up Sasha's wife
and went grocery shopping and I went to the apartment to set down my things.
Along the way, Sasha sat on the cellphone and made crazy U-turns in streets
with 10 lanes of traffic. People don't observe all the traffic laws and
can often bribe their way out of offenses if stopped by a cop but on the
other hand you can often get stopped by a cop looking for an excuse to
get something from you. There are few parking meters; they had them on
the main streets but they ran on tokens not coins; people had their cars
towed and the Supreme Court said that towing people's cars away was an
unfair deprivation of property. There are enough parking spaces (including
pulling up onto curbs) in Moscow at this point so people put their cars
anywhere; it looks a bit disorderly but anyone opening up parking garages
will have to contend with a psychology that says why should I pay for something
I can do for free? Dinner at a tropical looking place with the trees and
rocks at a shopping center that looked exactly like a typical upscale shopping
mall in the US. Restaurant prices are still high and a bit higher than
Manhattan but quality is good although cake tends to look better than it
tastes; I ate my rice and veges still being quite conservative from the
road trip and not having slept the previous night. The lights are coming
on now and the bridges and streets are all lit up in color and it is very
festive. It still gets dark after 10. Time to go home to bed. I have a
2 bedroom apartment to myself with all new floors, carpets, furniture and
appliances from Europe and a jacuzzi in the bathroom to boot. There are
2 front doors for safety and a leading Moscow politico is my neighbor.
It is a 24 story high apartment building with digital security entry but
the lobby and mail room looks awful. The concept of a condo association
in these now privatized buildings is just starting to take root and soon
enough the tenants will organize themselves and do things such as fix up
the lobbies and landscape the public areas. Meanwhile, it is bedtime for
bonzo.
Saturday...Got up around 2. Sasha had to leave
Moscow for the day so I am not under pressure to do anything. Enjoyed some
of their famous black bread, cheese, blood orange juice from Italy and
leftovers from last night's dinner. Reading the local English language
publications. Moscow has a lively expatriate press that is written for
by Russians and the articles are on target. Long pensive stories about
politics, front page stories of mob shootings, exposes of wasted US foreign
aid money in Kazakhstan by foreign consultants and local politicos in collusion
lining their pockets. There is also some really radical English weeklies
with nightlife guides rating the clubs on the flathead factor (ie: 2 stars
means just don't bump into anyone with such a haircut; 3 stars means you
might get rubbed out by such a mobster) and printing transcripts of Russian
officials talking like shipworkers. There's plenty to read and the press
seems free but there are also lots of rumors still circulating and I can't
yet tell which of them work their way into the press. A rumor circulated
of an impending gas shortage so people were making a run for gas stations
while I was there and you saw lines and stations running out. I was told
that this is unusual though. I certainly didn't see anybody queuing for
anything else there in public areas.
At 5pm I started to walk along the main drag in
this residential neighborhood near the university. Leninsky Prospekt (Avenue)
is filled with stores with big windows now showing things you would want
to buy. There are Moscow 850 signs everywhere. People are carrying around
nice looking shopping bags and are happy. Groups of young people sit in
parks drinking and chatting. 5 year old girls with their parents and the
kid is either swigging a beer or a soft drink that looks like it and comes
in a similar looking bottle. Street crossings come with working traffic
lights and walking signals. Hair salons have been spruced up and hair cuts
run from 5 to 50 bucks. What's missing are coffee houses, video rentals
and budget dining; there is nothing between McDonalds and fancy eating.
Either you eat fast food or make a federal project out of dinner with a
hefty price tag. Starbucks Coffee would do well here but they've already
told me they're focused on Asia/Pacifica and won't even look at other regions
for at least another year or two.
As I walk into the center of town, the streets
leading toward the Kremlin have been totally fixed up with the facades
of the buildings having been totally restored and some new ones built.
There are now maps with English transliteration of Russian streets and
metro stations (go into a hotel and get one) so you can get around but
there are still no signs in public so it is not yet tourist friendly in
that sense. The metros (still a bargain at 40 cents a ride) are color coded
on the map but not in the metro station signage so transfers within stations
are confusing because you have to go to each platform and read the cyrillic
signs until you know where you are going. Fortunately, the metro stations
are beautiful and trains run really often and are nice inside with leather
seats. GUM the shopping mall has been completely transformed into a beautiful
upscale shopping experience with boutiques selling Europe's finest at European
prices. The Lenin Museum is gone; cathedrals along Red Square that Stalin
destroyed are now being rebuilt and indeed all over Moscow and the rest
of the country there is massive rebuilding and restoration of cathedrals
going on. The swimming pool a few miles from the Kremlin is now the home
of a huge cathedral being built that will become world famous once it is
done. Lenin is still buried in Red Square but the honor guard is gone and
I think he is still on display at certain times. The big open square next
to Red Square that was once empty and which 5 years ago I called the Biggest
Wasted Public Space I Had Ever Seen (Sasha reminded me) has been transformed
into the Most Beautiful Public Space I Have Seen In A Very Long Time. Known
as Manezh Square, it is filled with gardens, fountains, walking areas,
venetian railings and steps, statues, glass domes and pyramids and art
over an underground 4 story shopping mall. When I arrived an orchestra
was playing Russian marches and ballroom selections and grandmothers were
dancing with their grandchildren. I will say it again; Moscow is becoming
a happy and cosmopolitan place.
Now being nighttime, dinner up the street at Patio
Pizza which I found at random but turns out to be Moscow's first budget
dining chain. Still, a fettucini and salmon dish, juice, water and tiramisu
came out to $25 which is reasonable but overpriced since it was Pizza Hut
quality. Remember that VAT is 20% in Russia and the mob take their cut
so much of the overage in prices is eaten up by this sort of double taxation.
At least the VAT is being used to fix up the city. At the restaurant I
bought a telephone card to use in a phone that would work to call Sasha
on his cellular which worked 200 miles outside Moscow; yesterday Sasha
gave me 4 public phone tokens all used in vain to reach him. Even the regular
phones didn't connect me to any numbers for about 20 minutes. The phone
system is still not good there and cellular is necessary but costs about
90 cents a minute both calling and receiving. Fortunately, Sasha's company
pays his $1,000 a month bill. Returned home and listened to local radio;
a mix of Western and Russian music though the Russian contemporary is sounding
more and more Western everyday.
Sunday... The luck continues; have had great weather
throughout with sun and 70's during the day. Another late start due to
difficulty sleeping due to the early morning sunshine creeping through
thin curtains and the sound of cars whizzing by all night long. Took the
metro to the Revolution Museum on Tverskaya Street with the history of
Moscow. Unfortunately, I understood none of it but the displays were nice
so see it with a Russian. One guy I met on Red Square who hires himself
as a guide is Mr. Davidoff at 241.8509. The McDonalds at Puskin Square
is still a very busy place and it was filled with families eating Sunday
lunch, some dressed as though they came straight from church but it turns
out that Sunday morning is not when the Russian Orthodox go to church.
A Marriott just opened on Tverskaya Street and the Russia Movie Theater
offers a new concept in moviegoing. Showing current first run American
films (a good number of these are available), the price of the seat runs
according to where you sit and which film at which time you see. There
is a big public area where you can buy clothes and eat food even if you
don't see a movie which is a smart idea for a theater. Also, you could
sit around before or after the movie and eat which is pretty smart too.
Big video walls, smart looking bars, marble floors -- totally first class.
Wound up at the Palace Hotel; Sunday buffet there is $39. Sasha was there
and we headed to another shopping mall; very fancy with Tiffany, Cartier
and the rest in a Bal Harbor-type (famous Florida mall) setting. Prices
for Cartier are at Swiss retail with a 15% discount for cash.
Russians can buy with credit card and pay their
bills in dollars; they can have ruble and dollar bank accounts but because
of devaluation people prefer dollars and tend to spend rather than save
money in a society that does not yet give people incentives to save money.
Interest on a one year CD for a dollar account is 14% but there is no insurance
if the bank goes under and many banks are weaker than they appear. As in
Israel, VISA is linked to the bank account as a debit; there are no real
checking accounts. There are exchange windows everywhere (ie: supermarkets)
and the commission for exchange transactions is de minimis. There is also
a very good network of ATM's and you can use almost any American bank card
to withdraw funds straight from your bank account. We continued to Victory
Park, a huge memorial to the 20 million who died in World War II with the
names of the dead inscribed on the walls. It is a huge building with a
huge rotunda and various other rooms on several hundred acres with cathedrals
and various other items on site. It takes about 10 minutes to walk the
length of the site. Dinner at an upscale restaurant known as Pirate with
a Pirates of the Caribbean decor throughout. 3 armed guards and a metal
detector at the entrance. Obviously a sensitive eating establishment. Viking
salmon with potatoes and peppers, garden salad and a good piece of chocolate
cake. A $40 dinner. Prices are quoted in dollars but people pay in rubles.
Drove past the university area to see townhouses
that were being built around a lake 5 years ago; they are building third
stages now. The power elites have houses with big walls here too. Returned
to Red Square and the piazza where the orchestra was doing a repeat performance
of music from the 1950's after the War when people were happy. Dropped
by the Metropole Hotel which is definitely in the best location and where
prices have remained stable; their dining room is gorgeous and, like many
restaurants, offers live entertainment with dinner. At least musicians
can find work. Continued to the Arbat. The pedestrian mall looks the same
as it did; many of the street vendors have been temporarily removed for
the festival; there are now cafes along the mall. Nearby apartment buildings
offer new apartments for almost $300 per square foot or $3,000 per meter.
The Arbat which lines the traffic street is all lit up with stores selling
things to buy, auto showrooms, etc. and there is a huge supermarket right
at the entrance to the pedestrian Arbat. Not like 5 years ago where it
was a huge marketplace with old signs and nothing to buy. Most of the old
Soviet propaganda art is gone and is now sold in museum stores as collectibles;
a poster they couldn't give away now sells for $15. Many restaurants such
as Tren-Mos that pioneered the field 5 years ago have turned over but many
of the newer establishments have held their ground. Often you read in the
English press that a particular establishment's food "is improving." Prices
appear to have remained what they were 5 years ago but competitors are
upping the quality in order to fetch them.
There is an English language newspaper filled with
Employment ads. There is good employment opportunity here, particularly
in consulting. Experience requirements are not so demanding. Hardship perks
for Moscow employment are going down though as the city becomes more cosmopolitan.
Employees and landlords connive to inflate leases, pass kickbacks and bill
the foreign company. Good opportunities here include securitization of
municipal debt for cities other than Moscow; consultancies involving Russians
as opposed to just a bunch of foreigners who really don't understand things;
and flipping commercial leases. Rents are even higher than Manhattan; real
estate values are stable but down a bit after overheating. There is not
too much loyalty here; people are as good as their last deal and bribery
is absolutely necessary to get anything. The system as a whole is still
bureaucratic and costly involving licenses, fees and taxes (though people
tend to avoid taxes).
There is a strong feeling that the New York Times
and Wall Street Journal do not really understand what is going on here.
The people running the country such as Chubais are profiting and very much
a clique; their training was socialist and they have no real expertise
and thus defer to western consultants who also don't know anything but
who dip into US aid which greases the wheels for them and also secures
American companies the deals they want such as in Azerbaijan where some
American companies literally stole the rug from underneath some other oil
companies recently. The stock market is up 100% but definitely fixed by
a few people; some banks that appear strong really only have a few depositors
based on bribing those depositors to deal with that bank. If those few
people go elsewhere, the bank goes under. People are afraid of wire taps
from business competitors; Sasha's office has a paper shredder instead
of garbage can; his screen saver is password protected; and there is fear
that the average Russian will revolt against this massing of wealth by
a few elites. On the other hand, the average Dmitry is better off than
he was. 5 years ago he had bread and boiled water; today he has juice and
cheese and can drink the water. There is good toilet paper, paper towels
and kleenex. True, his neighbor might have a tv and vcr so he feels jealous
and worse off by comparison. But his standard of living is objectively
higher. Yeltsin won his most recent term because this Boris voted for him;
not because the banks paid for the election but because common sense prevailed
and the average bloke understood it. Those that adjusted and made themselves
serviceable in the new economy (meaning that if you were an educator, scientist
or obscure engineer you had to find a new job) have improved their lots;
those on pensions have fallen through the cracks and unfortunately there
is little they can do to help themselves.
Monday...A morning walk to see people heading to
work, buying their fruits (the supermarkets import medium quality at high
prices; the kiosks sell from the farmers what is available internally),
and otherwise walking along the treelined boulevards and parks in between
the streets which helps make Moscow a particularly green and livable city.
Even the ugly horseshoe-styled apartment complexes open up into very green
courtyards. After some conversation and calls from Sasha's office, a company
car braved the midday traffic to get me to airport. Expect a good 30 minute
line passing customs on the way to airline check-in; arrive at least 60
minutes before the flight (almost 90 is best to be safe). Get a white customs
form to fill out from the Delta window in the airport lobby; even if you
already have the landing card get another one anyway and fill it out. Just
do it in case they ask you for it and send you back. They didn't in my
case but I was told to do this anyway. In normal cases, you would have
a problem here if you didn't register your passport within 3 days of arrival
in the country by sending someone with your passport to the police station
(if you stay in a hotel you don't have to do this) but since I wasn't there
3 days I was exempt as a transit passenger. Still, at this time you must
have a hotel reservation and voucher in order to get a tourist visa so
you pay $150 to a travel agency to fake a voucher with some hotel and take
care of the paper work with the Russian embassy or consulate here in New
York. It can be done in as little as 3 days if necessary (maybe even 24
hours but I'm not sure).
You can change roubles to dollars after passing
passport control (the lady at Delta check-in said I couldn't but she was
wrong; wrong information still persists although she probably never went
past the control so how would she know?) and the commission was something
like 20 cents. Duty free shopping is OK and you can buy the stuff you didn't
have a chance to buy elsewhere such as music of Russian marches and the
Red Army choir. We left the gate on time but sat on the runway as planes
landed and took off at this busy but one runway airport. A beautiful daytime
flight with a flyover of St. Petersburg where you could pick out the landmarks,
the Scandinavian fjords and an awesome view of the glaciers and peaks of
Greenland. Sit on right side both flights in terms of views and glares.
Arrival on time in New York with quick exit (one thing that is good to
do is give your bag to a flight attendant 30 minutes before landing for
her to put into the first class closet telling her you need a quick exit)
and to take an empty seat in the front of the aircraft just before landing.
After arriving in New York, the taxi line was horrendous but there is a
nearby bus stop with busses every 10-20 minutes to the subway station and
then you take the train into Manhattan; it goes up through Brooklyn and
southern Manhattan along 8th Avenue to 34th, 42nd
and 59th streets (among others north and south). The bus takes
about 20 minutes to the train; and train runs every 10 minutes or so and
takes 45 minutes to midtown Manhattan and the whole thing costs $1.50.
No doubt it was faster than a taxi would have been with the whole world
returning from Labor Day weekend. Remember that going to Kennedy the shuttle
bus runs in a circle and it could be a while till you hit the terminal.
I don't know exactly how it works in reverse but the Port Authority of
New York / New Jersey runs the shuttle bus and can be called for information.
So, all in all, Moscow is now grand again (St.
Pete I am told has changed a lot less) and even somewhat happy. It now
appears ready for business and tourism though there is that knotty feeling
just below the surface that not all is that secure. Of course, if everything
were obviously just so, there would be no rocket science and everybody
would be in there doing business. 5 years ago I was not ready to recommend
doing anything there and it was a terribly depressing place to be. Not
so now. Clearly it is important to be cautious and to have the right associate
and there is much there that involves a pain in the buttsky. But there
is much still to be done and those that are there are being rewarded if
they follow the rules and stay out of lines of business that should be
left to the mafias; otherwise, as long as one is not too rich and conspicuous
or in a line of work that involves a high risk profile (ie: jewelry, precious
commodities, banks) he will be left alone as crime is targeted; not random.
Those that are running the country will continue to stagger along and true
reform is probably another 10-20 years away when the next generation of
western-trained russians take over; their elders are not yet giving them
the chance to run things; it is still more profitable to them (though not
for Russia as a whole) to partner up with westerners who offer advice backed
with money. Dirty the job is, but this money is filtering down to infrastructural
improvements that is beautifying Moscow and making goods and services available
in quick fashion that is helping to raise the livability of peoples lives
in the capitol if not yet the rest of the country.
Beautiful new Manezh Square near the Kremlin and
Bolshoi theaters.
To take the city photo
tour, click here. |