Lonely Aravah border crossing from Israel to
Jordan. A 5 minute solo walk to a place a light year away.
I visited Jordan twice during this period, first
on tourism/business then for business only, both times for 3 day periods.
It seems that Jordan has better relations with
Israel than with the Palestinian Authority so you must cross either through
Aravah near Eilat or Sheikh Hussein near Tiberias. As the Allenby
Bridge is not an international crossing point since it's in a place that
isn't Israel or a Palestinian state, you can't get a visa at that border
or at the Jordanian Embassy in Tel Aviv (until May 1995 as to the Embassy).
This is inconvenient as Allenby is half an hour drive from Jerusalem (allow
almost an hour with all the passport checks on the roads). Fortunately,
you can reenter Israel through Allenby. And frequent travelers can
apply for a 5 year multiple entry visa to enter via Allenby from a Jordanian
embassy abroad, but not in Amman. I met with the director of the
Interior Ministry who would only tell me he didn't know of the visa and
that he was confused with all the changes. The Interior Ministry
is the last place to go to find out anything or to get anything (same in
Israel). The UPI and Newsweek correspondents crossing the Bridge
told me how. By the way, when I visited the second time, I was told
by an official at the Jordanian embassy in Tel Aviv I could enter through
the Bridge. I was turned back; the Jordanian border patrol has no
ability to bend the rules; in Jordan rules are followed if and when they
exist. Turns out they did change the rule February 1 and then cancelled
the change two days later and didn't tell anyone. At this point,
all the border people there know me since I've been screwed with so much.
The root of the problem according to well placed
travel industry sources is that King Hussein is trying to choke Jericho
(read that "Arafat") by making it miserable to cross there. Seems
self-destructive to me since the only ones being affected are the foreign
passport holders. His tourism and interior ministers have been in
office for 20 years, were told all the time to maintain the status quo,
and are slow to change with the new realities. Since the king trusts
them, he either doesn't know what's going on or hasn't found anyone he
trusts to replace them.
The Allenby crossing which, sooner or later will
exist in both directions, is one of the worst in the world. The Jordanians
send a bus once an hour or so and you just sit on it until the driver decides
it's full enough. You could walk the distance but you can't.
Your passport is looked at about 5 times by people within eye distance
of each other and on the Israeli side they go through everything with metal
detectors and x-rays. Allow between 1-2 hours to cross. (If
you're Palestinian, it's hell with strip searches and what not.)
It's almost worth it to drive north where it's more pleasant, cheaper on
the exit tax and much faster. The officials on the Israeli side advise
the best time to cross Allenby from Israel is 8 am. Shared taxi is
$9 to and from Abdo Taxi located just behind the main street across from
Damascus Gate.
The second time I had to take a private taxi to
the northern crossing from Allenby; one hour and $66 (figure close to 1:45
hours from Jerusalem). There are no shared taxis yet from Jerusalem
to the northern crossing. Then an hour and a half to Amman for another
$38 (but I shared so it was half that.) The first time I flew Arkia
50 minutes to Eilat ($80 -- double for round trip; $40 youths under 29
if seats are available after 7pm the night before), spent some hours walking
around there looking at the tremendous boom in hotels that has come up
in 11 years. The place is filled with tourists even midweek and there's
plenty of things in the area to do. The airport
is right in the center of town, there is tourist
information all around and you can check a bag at the central bus station.
I was curious to see the old Sonesta Hotel which
I'd heard so much about, now the Hilton in Taba, and although the border
is 5 minutes away, it takes a good 15 minutes to cross with stupid forms
to fill out on the Egyptian side. This has basically killed the hotel
and it ain't worth seeing. The hotel may have been interesting 10
years ago but compared with the new hotels in Eilat, it's nada. Eilat's
waiver of the 17 percent VAT makes it worthwhile to shop and competition
among the hotels makes it very reasonable to eat good food. A rib steak
at lunch at a top hotel is $12. Isrotel's Royal Beach Hotel is gorgeous
but quite expensive at over $200 a night. The area is naturally scenic
and restful and very tourist-friendly.
Arrived at the Arava crossing point approximately
4:30 pm Monday January 23. Arava is a 10 minute bus ride from Eilat's
Central Station. I crossed the border alone in a few minutes.
You walk down a lonely dirt path. If you cross in the morning, it
takes over an hour. The bus tours from Eilat to Petra all take 2
days because of all the waits; to do Petra in a day it pays to stay the
night in Aquaba or cross in the afternoon and go from the border there
by taxi for the night. At the border, you buy a visa for $22.50 and
pay Israel $16 ($27 at Allenby) to exit. I got into a taxi and rode
around Aquaba looking for a hotel. There are several hotels next
to each other along the water. I chose the Aquaba Hotel for $60 a
night.
That was medium; you could go for $100 a night or $30 a night in less desirable
center city. This hotel is run by the Government, is on the water,
and has nice cabins for rooms after the main house fills up. Also
has a nightclub, restaurant and includes breakfast buffet. Perfectly
adequate. Good heating, nice towels and clean spacious rooms.
Besides, Eilat's hotels are much more expensive, even if the food is about
the same.
I made a mistake and skipped the $9 buffet the
hotel was offering (not enough vegee food) and had fish at a nearby hotel
seaside restaurant; the fish alone was $15. Jordan sticks tourists
with 20% tax on rooms and food (except at the Government hotel I stayed
at) and the tax makes up the difference with Eilat on the food. USA
Direct Service pays; they charged me $15 to call Israel for one minute
from my hotel phone. Aquaba has red oranges! No problem with
the water anywhere I went in Jordan.
There's no tourist information center at the border;
no hotel reservation service in Israel; no Aquaba guide at the hotel; no
details of group tours to Petra. At the northern border there was
a tourist info center but it was closed when I arrived at late afternoon
for what again was a crisp crossing. You have to find somebody who
will arrange a private taxi to travel or go to an agency who will take
a big commission. There is public transport but either you have to
reserve it in advance or I just didn't figure it out. The hotel staffs
certainly don't tell you how to do it. Aquaba is really quiet compared
to Eilat; not much tourism there and not compelling to visit except that
you can do Petra much more conveniently by doing so and Aquaba is a fairly
pleasant place to relax. There are things to do in the area (ie:
jeep tours in Wadi Ram) but the marketing isn't as obvious as in Eilat.
There is good hotel accommodation in Petra so one could cross in the afternoon
and go there directly.
* * *
I walked the sleepy streets of Aquaba feeling quite
safe and ran into 5 Ahmeds from the Jordanian Military College. We
spent about 2 hours together. Things they never heard before:
King Hussein warned Dayan and Golda about the 1973 War before it happened;
Israel put tanks on the Jordanian border in 1970 to keep the Syrians out;
and the USA has had plans for 30 years to invade Jordan to keep any invader,
including Israel, out. "Are you sure this is true?" they asked.
"Ask the King; he's no longer denying it," I answered.
Basically, they reacted with a businessman's enlightenment
when I said that the USA essentially had two interests in the Middle East:
stable oil prices and demand for American military hardware along with
reliance on the USA. If that meant fueling a certain amount of instability
by helping Israel, moderate Arabs and fundamentalists, depending on the
season, so be it. And if giving Israel some free samples or "spend
it in the US credits" on the military side would fuel demand for the Saudis
to spend six times the amount, so be it. It's not so much that the
USA loves Israel.
Jordanians may or may not want to visit Israel;
one thing keeping them away is the knowledge that it's mucho expensive
to go there. I was a bit surprised at the lack of interest among people
in Aquaba to see what's in Eilat five minutes away. They don't really
know how big Eilat has become, particularly considering the difference
in tourism between the two places. Some of them have a Moslem problem
with going to visit Israel. They watch Israel Television Arabic news
and English films but combine what news they hear from Israel, Jordan and
the rest to figure out the truth which they figure is somewhere in the
middle. On satellite, they get all three Israel TV channels but many
of them avoid the second channel which they feel is too pornographic.
They don't seem to listen to the Israel Radio, except maybe the Arabic
service. Rich Jordanians really go for satellite television.
These points are developed later.
* * *
Tuesday morning, I got an 8:30 start by private
taxi to Petra. It took almost 2 hours to drive on decent roads.
Scenic drive with some army checkpoints along the way. Take plenty
of dollars or dinars there; no VISA in Petra. The Government just
raised the fees six-fold. It costs $30 to get in and another $30
for a horse and guide. The chap who walks you and your horse gets a $7
tip. Sorta high but there's 350 horses and walkers and not enough
tourists so that's his whole day's pay. Otherwise, you walk everywhere.
Some people spend days there. Hikers can sneak in; ask the students
who back-pack.
You can do the basic tour in 2 hours. What you
miss is what you'd see if you like to climb 1,000 steps in order to reach
such things as a monastery on top of a mountain. The basic
tour is enough for me as most of what you see are facades; to actually
climb inside is to be disappointed unless you like standing in big empty
dark chambers with tall ceilings of rose-colored rock. If they'd
hang chandeliers there you could have some magnificent banquet halls.
A camera doesn't do justice to Petra. You ride
through some grand gorges and see Nabatean temples built into rocks.
What's there is small compared to what was there before an earthquake drove
it underground many centuries ago. There's some amphitheatres and
wide open spaces with mountains and valleys. Every few seconds there's
something new to look at. It's not too touristic yet; if you step
over the edge of the mountain you will fall straight down! My guide,
Mahdy al-Nawafleh, is a Beduin who is 29 but looks like 40. He majored
in history and has been guiding for 5 years. Telephone 03.336.665
fax 336.666.
Nearby Petra is the town of Wadi Mousa. Mousa
means Moses and is reportedly the place where Moses hit the rock.
There's a spring there. I ate lunch with my driver there. Pita,
falafel, hummus, veges and salad came to 75 cents. Only cheap thing
of the whole trip -- of course I was off the tourist track. Might
find better prices on souvenirs in town rather than at Petra. I bought
a souvenir video for $19 after a bit of a discount. Big mistake; it was
shot in the 1960's and hardly shows off the sites. It also shows
quite a bit of Israel as if it was Jordan, which it was at that time.
Two hour ride to Amman where 1.2 million of Jordan's
4 million live; with nearby Zarka, half the total population is within
a half hour's drive. The last half of the drive is on an excellent
highway. Picked up some Jordanian equivalent of Israeli "krembo"
chocolate mousse/cookie snacks that had my cousin Yochi written all over
them. Amman has doubled in population in 20 years and didn't have
a traffic light 20 years ago. Now it's a nice modern city with wide
streets, nice sidewalks and squares and a clean orderly feeling and kinda
quiet in certain places.
Arrived in Amman about 4:30 and paid my driver
$75. Could have done this far cheaper with public transportation
but who is going to try to figure this out as long as time matters.
Besides, the driver spent an hour in Amman with me as I found my way to
a friend who gave me the cash to pay him (I had run out of cash and the
bank machines don't pay out on American cards) and then shuttled me to
my hotel where I got the Jordanian courtesy rate ($60 includ. tax vs. $130)
via the head of the maintenance department who was a friend of this friend.
Stayed at the Amra Hotel, a high level 4 star hotel
part of the Intercontinental Chain in a pleasant residential neighborhood
located further away from downtown but not at all inconvenient. Cable
TV, Israel is a local channel, swimming pool and health club and shopping
center attached to the hotel. I knew I was in another world when
I heard from my room the mosque call people to prayer about 6:30.
They pray 5 times a day, the first being about 4 am. I am told they
get up to pray and go back to sleep. The second visit my hotel was
right near a mosque at the Islamic College and it was a royal pain listening
to "Allah Akbar" over the loudspeakers every morning at 4 am for 15 minutes.
That hotel was the Shepherd located about 7 minutes walk from the 5-star
Intercontinental. It has about 30 rooms (they gave me a suite upgrade
gratis as they were about 75% empty and I was booked in by a business contact),
charged me $45 a night with the taxes, and is much cheaper on the food
and phone call bill (dinner and two days worth of local phone and faxes
came out to almost $10). It's close to many locally priced services
and in a nice area. If you can live with a room that's not terribly
well heated and the 4 am prayer service, it offers friendly service and
the other advantages I've mentioned. As far as location in a general
sense, the issue is irrelevant as the city is large enough that you have
to drive anywhere to get anywhere and a cab is never more than $2-3 if
you drive 20-30 minutes cross town. Since you can't build more than
6 stories high generally, there's no place to expand to except cross town.
* * *
I met with two sets of friends in the lobby and
stumbled upon a Moslem engagement party. The happy couple, surrounded
by guests and video cameras, marched through the lobby with lululuing going
on around them. After my meetings broke up, I went to check out the
party and was invited in. Sat with the guests of all kinds and talked
with some of them. A most excellent band played very modern sounding
Arabic music and the singers were famous television personalities.
The 29 year old boy comes from a rich family and had been doing business
in Bangkok. Seems the parents felt it was time to get married and
fixed him up with a nice girl in Amman. Very nice party with several
hundred guests and lots of video screens and sit down dinner in the main
hall; the bride wore a red dress. Strangely enough, very few people
besides the family dance. Could be very boring to just sit and watch
these parties on a regular basis.
The entertainment continued in the lobby lounge
with a famous singer who sings Lebanese music of a certain singer who is
said to be hard to imitate. I had a late supper enjoying the $15
dinner buffet available in the coffee shop till 11. They have 3 buffets
a day there. Plenty of food to eat.
I met some very interesting people in the lobby
just as I had the previous night in Aquaba. Following are some people
in the 20-30 age bracket hanging around. In Aquaba I met a French
commodities inspector who had lived in the UK and Germany and so spoke
perfect English. Then there was a Jordanian who was in commodities
who had studied in a US university. He liked the US as a student
but would rather raise a family in Jordan. Several others I spoke
to felt similarly and reacted with surprise and sympathy when told that
many American Jews who want to live in Israel feel that the crime, drugs,
etc. of America is turning them off. In the Amra lobby there were
two Dutch people representing a Swiss factory selling seeds. Also
met a college student who was just hanging around the lobby. Born
in Kuwait, grew up in Dubai and studying in Amman, he wants to do a masters
degree in pharmacology in the US. He had been invited to the engagement
party and had gotten bored. We returned to the party late night and
spent 4 hours together on Thursday.
This last person, Imad, I called on before my second
visit. Since he lives in a new 3 bedroom apartment in an area with
a shortage of phone lines, I had to schedule my phone call with his friend
who lives 20 minutes away by car and has a phone. We agreed by phone
to meet in front of a school at 9 pm on the day I was to arrive.
When I got frustrated at the Allenby Bridge, it was only the knowledge
that Imad would be standing there on a cold night and that there was no
way to call it off by phone that caused me to go north to the other crossing.
The guy who I shared a taxi with from that border took me to his house
to meet his family. He is a Jordanian travel agent with 20 years
in the hotel business who just started his own company and had just been
in Israel for the first time to develop contacts. Even though he
had seen Israel on TV almost every day, he was shocked at what he saw but
still felt that Amman was nicer than Tel Aviv; he didn't like the tall
buildings and traffic jams. We snacked on apricot nectar (popular
for breaking the Ramahdan fast), tea and coffee (everyone there expects
you to drink tea or coffee at every meeting or encounter) and some pastries
which they break the fast on and he then took me to the schoolyard to meet
Imad who showed up just past 9.
I stayed at Imad's house (had to get even after
paying for that cab ride) which was nicely furnished and looked like anyone
else's house (new GE fridge, Sony audio/visual, family pictures, regular
furniture, and American music and videos) except that he has a Koran at
his bedside, the heating system wasn't in yet so we chilled out for the
night and he doesn't use or like toilet paper. Seems they clean themselves
with water like European ladies; if you consider what toilet paper for
a family of ten costs over a year they may be on to something. I
also noticed that at every place or home I ate there were no napkins unless
you asked for one (and then you sometimes got a kleenex instead).
They don't seem to mind sticky fingers. As long as I'm on the point
of etiquette, the Jordanians are similar to Israelis in the way they curl
up their fingers and wag them at you for "patience, please" and say "Ya-La"
("Go!") a lot. Some other similarities too in grunts and gestures
but too hard to describe.
* * *
If you "defile" the holy moslem land by praying
with your tefillin in the morning, do you face East to Jerusalem or West
in the sense that you're still really in the Holy Land? I mean, doesn't
the Bible say it's ours all the way to the Euphrates River? And what
about the infamous map the Arabs all say hangs in the Knesset showing Israel's
border extending east to Iraq? I decided I felt more like facing
West than East. Jordan feels closer to Israel than Miami, I guess.
Wednesday morning started out by driving with someone
who has taking his son to work at an airline office in downtown.
The son, about 25 years old, asked me twice if I was Jewish. I didn't
hide this from anybody and didn't have any problems. As you'll see,
I didn't avoid any subjects either. His father said his son had never
seen anyone Jewish before. I said to make sure we have dinner together
so he could ask the 50,000 questions he wanted to ask the first Jew he'd
ever see. I don't recommend skullcaps or Hebrew; they nervously equate
these things with ideology. Basically they don't mind the religion
you're born with as long as you don't flaunt it and make them nervous in
front of their friends whose reactions to you they aren't yet sure of.
The second trip I had a meeting with a 25 year old who also told me I was
the first Jew he had ever met who wasn't holding a gun. I spent a
bit of time explaining things to people I'd met. Some popular questions:
What's the meaning (and subtleties) of skullcap culture? What's the
business of kosher and shabbat? Don't think they don't know nothing
about Israel; they told me they all watch the Simpsons from Israel TV Wednesdays
at 7:30 and root for Macabee Tel Aviv's basketball team; seems they like
the tall dunking Yugoslav and Black American who play for them and consider
the team to be good.
Downtown is quite busy but orderly and clean. You
get traffic during the day but it moves. Streets are wider than Israel,
drivers are more courteous and people cross with the lights. Best
price shopping is here. A mosque is right at dead center. There
are some royal palaces nearby but these are hidden and not worth the drive-by.
A Palestinian refugee camp is also nearby and is akin to a city ghetto
in the old European sense. I visited Hanna's office which looked
like any office in any office building. Located in the Jabal Amman
area of East Amman, it is an older middle to upper class mixed zoning neighborhood
a few minutes from downtown. I asked why the King's and his wife's and
daughter's pictures are in every office, restaurant and car -- was it fear
or affection? Both, he said. Never hurts to look loyal if you're
visited by an official and people really like looking at the king's daughter.
Actually, people there really do like the king and appear to like his brother
Hassan who is to take over when he dies. More on this later.
We drove around looking at the various neighborhoods
and visited his nephew David who heads up Jordan's leading real estate
company founded in 1950 and which sold the Americans the land for its embassy.
Notes of the real estate conversation are appended hereto.
The Abdoun district is in Western Amman and represents
tremendous wealth as well as the outskirts of development in a rapidly
expanding city which has outgrown its Eastern banks in much the same way
Jerusalem is expanding naturally toward the East. (When I pointed
this out to them, they responded that they never thought of it this way
and agreed that whomever would tell the Jordanians that they had to freeze
their Western Amman building or forget about peace would be told to go
to hell.)
In Abdoun there are magnificent villas and shopping
areas to service them. People don't seem to have big back yards with
grass as they feel land is expensive and that such a yard is a waste.
They tend to either build big houses just for themselves or 3 or 4 story
houses and put their kids (even if married) onto the other floors so they
will live nearby. They like beautiful doors, glass, arches and tend
to put glass doors a few feet in front of the main doors, maybe so that
people won't have to wait in the cold.
What they don't do is put up big walls, guard dogs
and big security systems although some have video cameras to screen visitors,
and alarms with or without hookup to central station. Swimming pools
are popular and hardly anywhere did I see laundry sticking out of windows.
This lack of concern for security is important; most of the country is
dirt poor and only a few miles away. If these elites aren't worried
about their mansions, I am more likely to feel safe as a tourist and investor.
Basically, the country is pretty happy because things are getting better
all around. There are poor Moslems that are more fanatical but they
don't appear to be a threat. Outside the elite of the country, much of
the population is not too keen yet as to the peace.
If you go to the edge of Abdoun and look around,
there is nothing. Abdoun was nothing a few years ago. Nearby areas
such as the Garden of Roses Street and Swefieh were also non-existent several
years ago but have turned into thriving residential and commercial districts.
Smart land speculators will buy in the periphery. All new construction
is first class and looks of Belgian quality; eateries have marble floors
extending to the sidewalks and granite lining expensive windows and doors.
A scoop of premium ice cream was 35 cents. 3 expensive pastries from
a patisserie came to about $2. You can get nice hot rolls on the
street for next to nothing. No doubt that the expensive areas are
of higher standard than Israel. You also have your hummus and falafel
houses within Amman where you can eat dinner for 75 cents. One intriguing
point about small restaurants: the concept of family seating.
This means that only families and single women can sit in them. Single
guys or guys with gals can't sit down except in a section reserved for
them when it exists. It's a Moslem country and they don't want fraternization
in public. This means on my second trip my friend and I out for the
evening ate our ice cream in the car. Jordan attracts Gulf Arabs who enjoy
its relative freedom but there is no comparison between nightlife in Amman
with that of Israel. For starters, you don't have real pedestrian
districts there like Ben Yehudah Street or Dizengoff, just some streets
with a few restaurants, bars and clubs.
There are a few massive supermarkets in Amman run
by Safeway (two floors open 24 hours a day; the bottom is food and a Little
Caesar's Pizza shop, and the top is like a mini K Mart) but most people
shop in small neighborhood groceries. The only thing I couldn't find
was cream cheese. (Second time I found it in a grocery with a friend
and the French product was excellent. You wouldn't guess from the
way it was packaged that it was cream cheese. Think of a bar of Philadelphia
coming in 6 square slices.) Some things are more expensive than Israel
or the USA, some things are cheaper. Four AA batteries are about
$1.50; a big box of Kelloggs corn flakes is about $7; a cake mix is about
$1.50; a container of Head and Shoulders is roughly comparable to the USA.
Basically, not cheap but reasonable.
Gasoline is $1.50 a gallon and cars are more expensive
than in the USA. In neighboring Israel it's $2.40 and in Iraq it's
about 5 cents. Electronics are about 3 times as expensive as the
USA. Remember that a starting lawyer makes about $200 a week or so and
that's a better than average salary. A student or young professional
pays about $70 a month in rent and so can live within his means given the
above prices in Jordan. Although a car is necessary for Jordanians
as Amman is spread around and municipal bus service is not so good, taxis
are cheap. From the hotel I paid $2 to get to Safeway; from Safeway I paid
about 75 cents to get back to the hotel and even a bit further (I caught
it on the street and he ran the meter instead of me asking the doorman
for the cab). Actually, when I didn't have Dinars and instead offered
him a $2 bill which was actually thrice the amount, he refused to take
any money saying I was a guest. Same thing at the bakery which gave
me a discount. Imagine that happening in Israel. Actually,
the bakery goods were going to Israel where I was to be hosted that night
by a friend. I decided not to tell the bakery where the goods were
going (maybe I'd lose the discount).
In the afternoon, I linked up with Luis who drove
me around different areas of Amman and took me to his house for lunch.
I had to skip the home-grown rabbit but ate the other home-made vegee food.
Jordanians I met expressed strong preference for fresh food but eat take
out once or twice a week. Wives particularly want Thursday nights
off; pizza delivery just started, otherwise there's Chinese, Arabic, etc.
They enjoy a 2 hour lunch break but otherwise eat pretty much the same
kinds of foods Americans eat. Pizza Hut and KFC are widely available.
They want more American franchise restaurants such as Fuddruckers and Bennigans.
While on the subject of food: my second trip fell during the month of Ramahdan.
This means everything opens late and closes early for naps and people aren't
totally on the ball for a full month. Quite a few people profess
to fast but cheat. The ones who do can't wait to eat at 5 pm.
The restaurants are closed all day. Christians eat privately so as
not to irritate the Moslems around them and I was surprised to find out
that the two religions get along unusually well in Jordan. At one
meeting, I offered Israeli "Pesek Z'man" candy bars (my favorite) to break
the fast: they enjoyed them immensely. They were shocked when I told
them the Pesek Z'man commercial currently on TV was shot in Petra.
TV that month shows special entertainment programs at night and people
go out late after eating a big meal. Had I stayed an extra day I
would have attended such a breakfast at the Jordanian university with Imad.
One attraction of such public meals is that guys get to meet girls there.
Usually, if singles have a meal at home and they're Moslem, it's either
all guys or all girls. Moslem guys can cook, says Imad. Syrian
TV puts out a program about medieval Arabs at Ramahdan that is very romantic
and colorful and people are glued to their sets to watch it. Although
people figure Syria is dark and dreary since it is not democratic, I am
told by Jordanians and foreigners crossing the bridge that it's got beautiful
shuks, good buys and good nightclubs. Jordanian guys go there for
girls they can't get at home although the depressed Iraqi economy is increasing
the Iraqi market share in this regard.
They will soon have cellular service by Motorola;
meanwhile, the new sections of Amman presently wait 2-3 years for phone
lines. Many families and businesses are without one. Cellular
service will cost about 25 cents per minute and well over $1,500 before
you get to make the first call. In anticipation of this service,
the Jordanians are looking at the borders for people carrying phones more
than anything else; if you bring one in, hide it on your body. The phones
work in Amman off the Israeli system. People are buying phone lines
to hold for appreciation. The phone company is being privatized but it
will be several years in the doing.
Every Jordanian Palestinian I met in any context
was dressed like a European; in business they wear jacket, tie and sweater;
at night I saw jeans as well. They prefer Western music. The
other Arabs wear headdresses. They were prompt; returned all phone
calls, and did whatever they said they would do. They were courteous and
not pushy. In Amman, you can buy very nice clothes made in Europe
at very good prices; storekeepers are happy to bargain in certain contexts
but Jordanians do not normally bargain when they go shopping. A cashmere/wool
jacket from Italy can be had for under $200; Bally's shoes are on sale;
a nice suit made in Syria is available for $75 and you can have custom
made shirts, suits and the like made up from fine fabrics at Hong Kong
or better prices within 2-3 days. Fine china is also available.
Could be a surprise source.
* * *
Luis, who is a Christian Palestinian, and I talked
politics as he is a personal acquaintance of Arafat. He termed Arafat
an unintelligent but sane figurehead who makes no decisions but rather
implements whatever the people around him decide. He believes that
Israel has a year to make peace with Syria and the PLO or the whole area
will deteriorate. He says don't blame the radicals on Arafat; American,
Israeli and Saudi money started up the Hamas and it's now beyond Arafat's
ability to control this monster which in any event was created and exists
in opposition to him. He says the Palestinians are not going to support
Arafat as opposed to Hamas unless he can show they will get something more
than a jihad to liberate a garbage dump in Gaza and the 3 block town of
Jericho 75 miles away.
He thinks Assad is crazy for sitting on the fence
and that Jordan made peace with Israel to pressure Assad. He thinks
Israel is just plain impractical and therefore idiotically standing on
ceremony for not allowing the Palestinians to meet people in East Jerusalem's
Orient House. He says Israel's right wing is raising the Jerusalem
issue to stir up trouble more so than the Palestinians are doing.
He also says that troops must be withdrawn for free elections to take place.
The experience in Arab countries is that people don't feel free to vote
when troops are watching; in Jordan whenever there is an election all the
troops are sent to barracks and only the police are on the streets.
He expressed the general impression I got in Jordan
as far as a Palestinian state being a threat to Jordan. Palestinians
make up 90% of the Jordanian business community. They are making
a ton of money and know that if they controlled the government, they would
fight amongst themselves just as the Palestinians are doing on the West
Bank. Basically, they don't want to ruin a good thing by importing
Palestinian rule to the East Bank of the Jordan. They're quite happy
with Hashemite rule, thank you. On the other hand, they feel that
free movement of people between Jordan and the West Bank within a confederation
will help West Bankers achieve normal lives and business and perhaps make
them more reasonable to Israel's taste in the future.
Given that Israel is moving away from the concept
of free movement and toward the idea of total separation between peoples,
it seems unlikely that the peace Israel wants will be good for business
from the Palestinian point of view. As another example, I held a
discussion with a lawyer who mentioned that he was looking forward to the
peace since he has a lot of family in the West Bank and has never really
had the chance to get to know them. He's proud of the educated intelligentsia
the Palestinian diaspora has produced and fully expects to be treated as
an intelligent person when he travels there. The odds are he'll be
treated lousily when he does visit and he will be bitter. Think about
it; I, an American, went through 2 roadblocks on the way to the airport
in East Jerusalem and crossing borders in the Taba/Eilat/Aquaba tourism
district was a pain. Hardly like moving around in the Argentina/Brazil/Paraguay
border area tourism district where you could move freely without passports,
visas and nonsense.
I expressed the opinion that Assad has about 6
months to get the Golan back because the lousy Israeli economy combined
with the terror is making a change of government more likely this year.
Luis answered that if Israel doesn't make peace, the Arab world will return
to being hostile, and that even if it takes 20 years for Israel to dry
up, so be it. Many of the Jordanians I spoke to believe that Israel wouldn't
last a year if America didn't keep propping it up, especially since many
of the Jews that live there won't stay if they can't live comfortably.
On the second trip I advised them the Israeli response to this is that
the Jordanians can stand on their heads but that they need the peace (read
that "cash" and business) as much as the Israelis do and can't afford to
sacrifice this just for the Palestinians in the West Bank. They agreed
with this response.
The English press here (the daily Times and weekly
Star) are more subtle and sophisticated in their opinion and analysis columns
than I expected. For instance, an article complained about terrorism
stating that it was embarrassing Arabs and making them look like savages.
"Have we stooped so low that this is how Palestinians have to act?"
Another article accused the other Arabs of ulterior motives in making a
fuss over Jordan's claim to the holy mosques of Jerusalem. It said
that Jordan wasn't trying to claim anything for itself but that others
were making it look as if it was to make trouble. Not enough attention
is being paid to the press coming out of Jordan. It's not just a
bunch of anti-Zionist vitriol.
* * *
Luis and I visited a fortress ("Khan Zman") on
the top of a hill that 500 years ago was ruled by a sheikh. We had
a tea in the touristy restaurant there. Afterward, he returned me
to the hotel where I found a fruit basket compliments of the manager and
got ready for the evening. Amman is not a fascinating evening place
and because it's cool or cold in the winter, people don't go out as they
do in summer. For them, particularly Christians, Thursday night is
the big night out. Thursday afternoon and Friday for them is the
weekend.
Elias heard I was going out with Hanna's son for
the evening so he called me up to tell me he would be picking me up in
10 minutes to bring me over to his house to meet his wife and kids.
We went to his three story house with private elevator to have a drink.
Although the Christians always offer drinks, everybody I met seemed to
enthusiastically approve of the fact that I don't drink coffee or alcohol
or smoke, things that are very popular over there except of course as to
drinking by Moslems.
So Hanna's son and daughter and I headed out to
Quiz Night held weekly at the Intercontinental Hotel. Hosted by the
British Consulate, teams try to answer questions and the ones with the
most right at the end of the year win a prize. It's all in English
and several hundred show up. They hoped I could help. I barely
got 2 out of 10. Tough questions such as: What's colder --
minus 40 centigrade or fahrenheit? Which 3 ministers did Hosni Mubarak
bring with him to Jordan? What's the capitol of North Dakota?
An interesting question which I enjoyed hearing
in front of a large audience: Why did Jordan lose the convention
of the International Bar Association? Because Israeli lawyers were
disinvited. Evidently, the Jordanian Bar hasn't yet repealed its
bylaw prohibiting contact with Israeli lawyers. Such was told to
me by a 21 year old lawyer clerking for Amman's chief lawyer in the top
law firm of 12 attorneys. Seems there's only 50 lawyers that do real
corporate work though there's 4,500 lawyers in Jordan. And there's
only 2 tax lawyers as nobody really cares about avoiding taxes which altogether
(meaning income and hidden taxes) amount to 35 cents on the dollar.
In Israel, it's about 60 to 70 cents on the dollar. At present there's
no sales tax in Jordan but the IMF is forcing Jordan to adopt one.
Every business hires an auditor to prepare the tax returns; if you get
past the tough auditor you don't worry about the Government. The
real tax bite in Jordan comes in the purchase of anything remotely considered
a luxury good; a VCR officially runs $4,000; on the black market it's $1,500.
The lawyer, Ayman, is the youngest person ever
to graduate George Washington University Law School in D.C. with an LLM
at 21 as law is a B.A. degree in Jordan. He had some good Jewish professors
and friends and likes to discuss Holmes' judicial opinions and wrote some
interesting theses on maritime law and the peace treaty with Israel.
He is Moslem and says there can't be peace without Jerusalem. On
the other hand, he didn't really know the importance of Jerusalem or the
Wailing Wall to the Jews and didn't know that contrary to an agreement,
the Jordanians didn't let the Jews pray there from 1948 to 1967.
Once screwed, the Jews don't want to let it happen again, I said.
Particularly since if you take away the Wall, there's no Medina or Al-Aksa
(numbers 2 and 3 points for the Moslems) to turn to in the alternative.
The point resonated.
By the second trip, Ayman had checked out my story
about King Hussein warning Golda and Dayan in 1973 of the Arab surprise
attack and said he was royally disillusioned with the Arab world that was
no longer denying these events. "You find out that for 20 years the
Likud was talking to the PLO, the King was committing virtual treason by
coordinating with the Israelis, and everyone was essentially dealing behind
everyone else's back. The whole thing is a joke -- it's real bullshit."
Ayman's father used to be a high PLO official (Arafat's assistant) when
they lived in Libya during the 70's. Even though it's still forbidden
to have contacts with Israeli lawyers (news of the law's rescission reached
me after departure), he asked me to send him a list of top Israeli law
firms and contacts. He says he doesn't care if his firm (the top
firm in Jordan) isn't ready to do business with Israel and the law forbids
it; he doesn't want to be left behind and figures the law is so anti the
peace treaty the Jordanians signed that it would be struck down if challenged.
Don't get the idea that he's not without strong Palestinian sentiments;
he's just trying to deal pragmatically with reality even though he sees
that the Palestinians in the West Bank will be the only real losers out
of the whole regional peace process, to be discussed later.
That conversation occurred in the lobby of the
Intercontinental as we munched on the special Ramadan coffee & cake
menu as we did dessert at 9 pm. Ayman and I were joined by his friend
Muhammed who is locally educated and therefore not making too much money.
He wants out of Jordan. I met several young people who are dying
to go to the USA for a better economic future and was asked by several
people during my trip for immigration advice.
Ayman chose to return to Jordan where although
he makes one fifteenth of what he'd make in the USA today, he has a life
and the chance to really succeed as a big fish in a small pond. Since
he can take on his own clients, his boss is limited by law to 3 foreign
retainers (the excess of which he must pass along), and he gets commissions
for contracts he writes up, he figures he'll be making a fortune within
a number of years. Besides, he's already going to court every day.
I met on the second trip with similar 25 year old
people who go to work in black turtlenecks and slick Greenwich Village
looking suits and moussed up hair and who spice their Arabic with Englishisms
(although I heard a lot of Englishisms such as "OK" and "bye" during my
trips). Granted, there are plenty locally bred university graduates
that can't find work or get paid peanuts (like $100 a week to start, maybe
$7,000 a year after it gets good working for the bank). But if you
have foreign education and experience, you can get into real positions
real fast. One guy I met is 24. He graduated high school in
Kuwait at 15 (they finish young there), went to University of Delaware
and then worked at Chase Manhattan Bank in New York for 5 years.
Now he plays the stock markets all day and half the night for the Arab
Jordanian Investment Bank and for the bank's clients worldwide. He
is regularly quoted in Reuters reports that give economic news and analysis
on Jordan. Highly pragmatic, he noted to me privately that Jordan
and Israel were coordinating their economies so that people wouldn't try
to get a better deal across the border. He said he wanted to say
that to Reuters that day but decided he'd better not.
Another guy is 34, a Palestinian West Banker and
American citizen, who returned after living in the USA and consulting in
D.C. for several years. He is partner in a consulting and investment
banking firm in Jordan; they just handled the deal to build the Sheraton
Hotel and he produced a 250 page study for Chemical Bank on foreign investment
in Jordan. It's a lively market in that new issues on the Jordanian
exchanges have been way oversubscribed; it appears that Jordan doesn't
suffer from a lack of internal capital but rather from the ability to be
taken seriously. You get the feeling there's a nice mafia of twenty-somethings
being given wide latitude by their elders who know that progress is good
but don't quite know how to handle it themselves. There is a built
in cautiousness among the older people; "it needs negotiation, feasibility,
bla bla bla" is used to push off an idea that is new because it is new
even if they know they like the idea -- they just can't bring themselves
to say yes right away. Part of the problem is that to do anything
there is the belief (probably well founded) that you need many people to
approve of it within the government and have to watch whose toes are being
stepped on by a new business enterprise. In any event, either the
country will be doing well or will be bankrupt within 5 years with this
new generation on the loose.
End of second full day the first trip around, I
was returned to my hotel where I had a midnight grilled cheese and french
fries from room service; came to almost $6. I had been hosted by
so many people that I hadn't had a chance to spend a dime all day or have
five minutes to eat since lunch. Second trip around, I had 2 hours
to myself to eat one evening in between all the events and had a break
from 3 nights of hummus with some cooked mixed veges, grilled cheese, french
fries and fresh OJ. Ate in the hotel after walking around and not
wanting to just eat pizza -- bill came to a more reasonable $6 with tax
and tip.
* * *
Thursday started out with a quick tour of the Safeway
supermarket and a walkabout in the Swefieh district which I described above.
I then met Imad and we arranged a cash advance from a local bank which
represents VISA. Even the Citibank branch only gives cash advance
through telex and it takes 2-3 days. So you have to go either to
a branch of the Cairo-Amman or the Housing Bank; banks are plentiful and
decent but remember siesta. The Amra hotel will advance you up to
$30 a day; I arranged to get $60 to pay Elias back by having Elias ask
the manager to give me the advance and put it on my hotel bill. I'm
sure Jordan will fix this tourist problem soon.
We visited the Housing Bank shopping center which
adjoins the Plaza Hotel which is one of the 5 star properties in center
city. The Israeli Embassy is inside this hotel but will soon move
into an Abdoun villa. The shops are very nice but downtown shopping
is 25% cheaper. I didn't find an equivalent to the Jerusalem Canion
shopping mall or a real American style mall or a big department store.
We spent some time walking around the nearby neighborhood
and then grabbing some lunch, ice cream and pastry at another neighborhood
and then finally hailing a taxi to take me to the border. The private
taxi was $30 for the 40 minute ride once you reach the highway to exit
the city (allow an hour from the downtown depot); (hint: catch a shared
taxi at the central taxi/bus depot downtown; it cost me $12 with tip for
the ride solo -- would have been a fraction of this had there been other
passengers; this gives you an idea of what it should cost to get to Amman
from the Bridge if you don't take the bus that runs from the Bridge to
town). Very impressive highway with some beautiful views; there are
no signs directing you to Allenby (there called the King Hussein) Bridge.
Crossing at 3 pm took a quarter of an hour and again I crossed alone; second
time around the crossing was a pain and took close to an hour even at 2
pm so it's run of the luck. Pay $6 to exit Jordan, $2 to take the
bus across the bridge and entry to Israel is free. A bunch of Malaysians
were at passport control. The official said there's a lot of them
visiting Israel these days.
Once in Israel after my first trip, there were
no shared taxis at 4pm to take me to Jerusalem. So I had to board
an Arab bus to Jericho (nothing like the nice Israeli buses), get off at
the army checkpoint, wait a half hour for no bus to come, have a soldier
hitch me a ride to an intersection outside Jerusalem, get into a taxi that
went to someplace else and that finally took me to where I was going.
Generally, the whole commute is about 3 hours. Had I taken a private
taxi from the Bridge it would have cost about $30-35. Had I taken
a shared taxi, it would be $9. Had I taken public transportation
in Jordan, each trip (ie: Aquaba to Petra, Petra to Amman, Amman to the
Bridge) would have been in the neighborhood of $1-3. Only problem
was that while in Jordan I was on a tight schedule and didn't really know
where I was going so I didn't want to play around and, as I said, I was
walking around without money most of the time I would have needed to use
it.
Fortunately in Jordan, as long as you deal with
elites or walk around in central locations, most people speak English and
the signs are bilingual. Everyone I called over the phone at government
offices or wherever spoke either some or good English. English is
definitely a second language there for elites but don't count taxi drivers
among them.
All in all, an excellent trip for 72 hours though
the expenditure together with the travel to Eilat ran almost $700 (second
time around I was on business but more experienced and at a cheaper hotel
closer to cheaper food or home hospitality for a night so the 4 days came
to one-third the cost, even with that $70 taxi ride in Israel to the border.
Also, on that second trip I was too busy to spend money; in 2 and a half
business days I met with 12 people on 16 matters; I had substantial contact
with about 25 people in all over the 3 day visit). Still a bit of
a challenge for the independent tourist but the charm will be gone when
the place becomes touristic. Bilingualism there amid clean water
and friendly natives go a long way toward helping the tourist. Petra
is worth the trip and Jerash, which I didn't see, is supposed to be worthy.
Amman is not a sightseeing destination but it has other charms such as
good shopping which I have mentioned and which will definitely serve as
an alternative to a European stopover.
Expenditures would have been higher had I not been
hosted so much and lodged at the Jordanian rate. I might have saved
some money on carfare but I would have paid it back in extra days of travel.
I have never enjoyed such hospitality as was extended to me by my Jordanian
friends as well as the people I met during my stay. I was impressed
by the sites, the boom in quality construction going on all over the place,
the feeling of freedom and optimism felt by the people I met both in business
and political contexts, and the impression that one could do business in
Jordan. Jordanians exhibit class and honor and live in a clean and
orderly place. Having been recently in Russia and Israel, two places
that are in vogue as to business, I must say that Jordan beats out both
of them in quite a few of these areas.
* * *
There is a danger that Jordanians are expecting
too much from this peace. They are expecting the manna to fall from
the heavens and hanging from it will be "Made in Israel" labels.
They await tourism and business. Their press is trying to get them
to think more realistically after the initial euphoria.
In reality, there won't be much business from Israel
that will profit Jordanians. They probably won't like many Israelis
they meet. The Israelis are rougher, slicker and will walk around
with their cellular telephones looking like they want to do everything
in one day and to take advantage of the stupid Jordanians that can't be
trusted. Except that the Jordanians aren't stupid and aren't going
to take kindly to being grabbed by the fly-by-night opportunistic Israelis.
I commented that I believe the Jordanians will benefit from the rest of
the world taking Jordan more seriously now that it will appear to be a
more stable country no longer in a state of war with Israel. The
first trip the above was my impression; the second trip I heard from Jordanians
the fear they have of massive Israeli factories and marketers making mincemeat
out of the Arab world. They figure that Israelis look down on them
and will try to take advantage and to grab. They know Israel is strong;
they respect the "clever" Jew (I heard that word used a lot) for making
money, being thrifty and for building up a strong state against the odds.
They don't believe that the average Jew likes to kill people. On
the other hand, they find Jews to be cheap. A president of a major
travel agency said he strongly dislikes working with Jewish tourists as
they are always demanding the world and never want to pay for it.
If a Jew is "dirty" it's usually in a monetary sense. They don't
take kindly to tourists bringing in their own food and taking hotel towels.
The bellman at the Shepherd happily said he had just had a group of 40
Orthodox Jews and they didn't take a thing; he added that the Israeli tour
guide searched them all as they came off the elevator.
Of course, when they hear about kashrut it makes
them think twice about the brown-bagging. There's also the idea of
"who knows what will happen tomorrow" that drives Israelis but doesn't
drive Arabs the same way. The Jordanian's first reaction to the concept
is that if the Jews don't know what will happen tomorrow, that must mean
they feel weak. But, as I explained and they later agreed, it's more
complex. For example, the Jew will come to Amman and deal in the
short term for now because he isn't convinced the peace will last.
99% of Israelis know someone who either died or was wounded in uniform
or as a civilian and the daily news of conflict in the region is not just
statistical but personal. Kids in high school see their friends die
in the army and wonder if they'll be next. Everyone in Israel wore
gas masks during the Gulf War. So of course they drive like crazy,
aren't looking to buy real estate in Amman just yet and tend to grab what
they can since they don't know what tomorrow will bring.
In contrast, the Jordanians I spoke to said that
fewer than 5 out of 100 know anyone in the army who got hurt or died.
Terrorism is not an issue in Jordan which is very safe. Open opposition
to the King and not following the rules in Jordan are not just in the cards
-- not in a place where the King's smiling countenance is EVERYWHERE.
So time passes more casually. The Palestinians have a sense of time
but in a longer span -- say decades; the Hashemites I ran into have virtually
no sense of time and couldn't care less if you come in and visit Jordan
or not or do business there or not. The King is moving unusually
quick to solidify the new concept of peace; people over 40 say "We need
time to adjust; we're trying; time will solve all complications.
Just give us a chance to come around to all this."
Prince Hassan would be crazy to kill the golden
goose by doing anything to stifle the Palestinians. Of course, that
never stopped regimes from eradicating their brand of cosmopolitans among
them, the Jews. This shared history of outsidership and of being
despised among the nations -- a sort of kinship among enemies (the emphasis
on education and working hard to get ahead and then making money which
draws the jealousy of the society around them) -- is felt by Palestinians
more so than Jews; the Palestinians know about them and the Jews; the Jews
don't know about the Palestinians. Think about it; I shared a taxi
with a man who left Egypt and his family on his own to go to university
in Amman because a Palestinian couldn't get into an Egyptian university
in the mid 1970's. The guy working in the bank was thrown out of
Kuwait along with his family after the Gulf War.
For Jews, these are just not issues these days.
Jewish lawyers do not endure strip searches (which they find humiliating)
if and when they finally get to visit their grandparents in the West Bank;
forget about it if they want to visit a relative living in Israel proper.
Like the guy said to me a few pages back, every Jew he'd ever seen before
he met me had been holding a gun. The guy continued, even when I
visit the West Bank I talk to other Arabs who tell me that I'm not one
of them; it seems the West Bankers are jealous of the East Bankers as they
live richer more comfortable lives. They were shocked when I told
them that American Jews and Israelis also have little in common.
They figured it was of nature that all Jews are buddy buddy. One
Arab said to me "The Jews in business: if one falls, the others, even his
competitors, won't let him die. They will help him maintain some
dignity. Not like us Arabs that rejoice in it." Another said
to me: "My friend is the ambassador to Israel. The Israelis are bastards
in negotiations and stand on ceremony (ie: the meetings at Orient House).
But if you're pleasant with them, they always give in. If Arafat
and the West Bank Palestinians could only be pleasant instead of arrogant
with their demands, they could get things."
The point of these vignettes: personal encounters
help exchange information to break down misconceptions. The more
the peace promotes this kind of interchange, the better I think it will
stick despite the politics. On the second trip in Amman among the
elites, I got the distinct impression that people I met with were hoping
for invitations to visit Israel and that I would introduce them to more
Israelis. The Israeli Foreign Ministry says this is now possible
within limits.
* * *
Leading strategists in Israel report that no matter
whether Meretz, Labor or Likud heads up the next Government, they all agree
on the extent of territorial compromise which at this point is being dictated
by the military. Syria will get the Golan, troops will pull out of
the West Bank and concentrate in the Negev. Roads will criss-cross
the territories to enable the military to move from South to North and
to keep the populations away from each other. Palestinians will be
utterly kept out of Israel and Israelis in the territories will hardly
ever see Palestinians. Jerusalem and the settlements around it and
in parts of Gaza will be massively built up as military assets essentially
to keep the Palestinians from forming a contiguous line.
Essentially, the "peace" is "redeployment of forces
to more efficient positions." The next war will be with Egypt which
(a) has not solved any problems which it hoped to solve in 17 years of
peace, except for rebuilding its air force; (b) is unhappy seeing Israel
driving Middle East diplomacy; and (c) cannot tolerate Israel's nuclear
monopoly although it can't afford to compete. Egypt may be irrational
in sending a million men to the front as a sort of population and dissent
control but it has gone to war before for precisely such reasons.
Syria can't afford to go to war; in two weeks they will lose all their
GNP and foreign currency reserves. Since this peace based on cynicism
and anticipation of future war won't satisfy Egypt or the Palestinians,
the issue as to Jordan is whether they will tolerate such a peace or will
have no choice but to do so from an economic imperative. In any event,
all the parties know that, for the first time, any cost of future war will
have to be borne mostly by the parties themselves and that none of them
can afford it.
While Jordanians think the King has overcome his
cancer, the Israelis aren't convinced. Israelis (business leaders
and strategists) fear that Crown Prince Hassan won't last as King and want
to wait a few years before investing long-term in Jordan; Palestinians
fear he doesn't like them and will treat them worse than they are presently
treated. Hassan, educated but aloof, is trying lately to assuage
fears by becoming more personable and addressing their concerns. However,
they say they don't even think of trying to overthrow him; Israelis say
that no matter what Palestinians say they won't be able to resist the temptation
to try and, being 70% of the country, maybe they'll succeed. Clearly,
the cosmopolitan almost European Palestinians look down on the native Hashemites
as fools that sit around reading newspapers, talking on the phone and drinking
coffee except that they are needed as business partners in order to open
doors to the government.
The Beduin, who are considered to be really dumb
but who ruthlessly keep order in the country and equate the King with God,
are not as enamored of Hassan either but are expected to support him.
I was told by a 4 year Army officer that when Palestinians at the university
started chanting slogans against the King, within a half hour they brought
in the Beduin who shot and killed ten students, took over the campus for
2 weeks and gave everyone hell. Calculators were confiscated and
students holding them were told (even when they appealed to officers) they
were carrying espionage material (the Beduin don't know what they are)
and jailed for 2 weeks without hearing. A girl slapped a Beduin in the
face as he came into her brother's apartment; he picked her up, climbed
six flights of stairs and threw her out the window.
How to make sense of this conflicting gibberish,
much of which is in peoples' heads? The root of the challenge of
the peace is mutual suspicion based on lack of contact of a positive nature.
Israelis and Arabs don't trust each other. Israelis say: the Arabs
just tell you what you want to hear. They talk a lot and do nothing.
They will invite you into their house and stab you after you leave."
With this conclusion, I can't believe anything I hear.
I got the impression across the board of elites
-- Palestinians and Jordanians, ages 8 through 80, Christians and Moslems
-- that I was talking to reasonable and sophisticated people more or less
on the same wavelength (usually depending on age). I got the impression
that West Bankers might in time become more reasonable once they, like
their East Bank brethren, had something to lose, because Palestinians by
nature are really more cosmopolitan than the native Arabs around them.
Israelis, particularly natives and Sefardis, tell you that's Western naivete
at work. "We lived with them for 50 years; you don't know the neighborhood."
True, but most of these people don't know any of these people personally
and don't speak Arabic. When they do see them, it's in a military
context.
You'd think the up and coming generation of Sefardi
Israelis would have more in common with the Arabs than the European stock
that runs the country. But after my experiences, it's clear that
the Sefardis' experience with Arabs leads them to utterly mistrust them
while the cosmopolitan Ashkenazis mix better with the Palestinians.
Rabin and Peres may be racing not only against time but a generation and
cultural gap as well as they look at the next generation of Israelis coming
to power.
I don't know; I spoke to people who have e-mail
addresses on Internet, watch MTV and the Simpsons, eat at Pizza Hut, walk
around with NBA-logoed basketball caps, and play the same games such as
soccer, basketball and tae kwon doe. I've had more interesting conversations
with guys my age in Jordan than similarly aged co-religionists in Jerusalem
or the Upper West Side where the conversations are limited to Jewish geography
or "Is God Merciful?" Having travelled for business in countries
such as Israel, Jamaica and Russia, I compare Jordan favorably when it
comes to follow-through and professionalism and the general feeling that
you say X and the other person understands you.
In political conversations, I drew a distinction
between presenting my own views and presenting information that would inform
them of what Israelis of various stripes think and say. The distinctions
were expressly made and confirmed and I have no doubt they understood and
appreciated the differences. I made it clear that we were meeting
to exchange information, not to score points although in fact I have very
little argument with anything I heard. I was told several times that
it was appreciated that I was not sugar-coating my analysis and presentations
as to controversial issues, that all subjects should be discussed and that
long term relationships would best be served by honestly putting all the
cards on the table.
Do I take what I heard in what I thus think were
candid conversations with a grain of salt? Or am I, the unemotionally
involved American lawyer, able to see more clearly than the Israelis who
tell me otherwise? Reporters I talked to feel they are being talked
to candidly. I thought so too. But they add that if you feel
confused, you're on the right track. C'est la vie. |