| The
Suggestion for this Poll:
Thinking about the NY Times piece we touched on
last week -- what are the greatest inventions of the 20th (and 19th, or
even all-time) century. Why don't you do a global thoughts posting posing
that same question. I think the responses would be fascinating. You can
pose it to include reasoning, and reasoning as to why they excluded other
choices (e.g. the Internet as unnecessary, or even the computer as overrated....).
Sam Mosenkis, Attorney, New York City
The Poll Question: the new york times recently
posed the question: what was the greatest invention of this past century
or of the millennium? many inventions were discussed. some were nominated
and others rejected. i've been asked to run a poll and find out what you
think: What was the greatest (most important) invention of the twentieth
century or of all time up to the present? If you eliminated certain things
after a lot of thought or straight out decided that a certain thing should
NOT be considered all-important (but you think others might think otherwise),
state your argument for eliminating that item from your consideration.
Just for starters, I will propose a few items for
your consideration:
Electricity (invented last century but used this
century; Powered Mobility (ie: auto, airplane; spaceship); Computer; Internet;
Atomic Bomb.
Responses will be posted to the global thoughts
website to the extent you permit.
Responses:
the greatest "inventions" are discoveries: entities
already out there but not previously recognized for their usefulness. In
my Medically biased opinion, Antibiotics are the greatest discovery in
the past century. No other has contributed to saving as many lives nor
has any other wiped out so many devastating and life-claiming illnesses
as have Antibiotics. the irony is that they'll likely be the greatest failure
of the coming
century, as more and more bacteria are growing
out with genes for Antibiotic resistance.
Ethan Ciment, Medical, New York City
I choose the computer as the most important invention
of the century. Many of the items on your list couldn't be achieved without
the computer - internet, modern airplanes and cars, atomic research etc.
The computer is on other dimension as it is not
only a tool but also a concept, a language, a way of life, communication,
social relation. It is possible to think of our life without many of the
other tools but the computers took control of us in work, for instance,
i can't imagine working without it.
Gilead Hellman, Business Consultant, Jerusalem
The transistor, of course, that was easy... I am
an electrical engineer. Aside from that, I may go with the flush toilet.
Joe Wetstein, Computer Networking, Washington DC
Joe forwards these other replies: Disposable diapers...
I do not believe that electricity was invented. It was discovered and harnessed.
My vote is for beanie babies.
The snooze button!
Gustavo Arnavat, Investment Banker, New York City
The toilet bowl and indoor plumbing. Best invention
hands down.
Avi Ciment, Business, Miami Beach
State of Israel (re-invented), Theory of Relativity
and Computers. If I Have to Choose One: Computers
Isaiah Jenks, Business, Miami Beach
in my opinion the most important thing in this
millennium, to let the peace be around the world specially in palestine,
and the people take there right.
Soha Ed-Dridi, Hi-Tech, Dubai
The "greatest invention" (measured by assisting
human progress /making life more pleasant & fun) ever is probably the
wheel or perhaps a metallurgical invention like the blade or nail (God,
what I'd give for the patent on any of these). Greatest invention this
century using the same advancement/fun definition above would be electricity/effective
contraception, or in the perfect symbol of both electricity and fun: the
electric guitar (what blessed joy).
Richard Pratt, Attorney, Washington DC
20th century: the computer. (Remember that ENIAC,
the first [insert twenty adjectives here] computer, was born a few blocks
from our former abode at Penn.) All time: agriculture, followed by writing.
John Ashbrook, Insurance, New York City
Personally, I can't decide between the tampon and
the contact lens.
Daniel Tunkel & Rachel Wetstein, London
Are discoveries included, or just inventions? For
example, the discovery of DNA would be my choice for the biggest scientific
development this century. If we stick to inventions, my heart tells me
the telephone (invented by a Scot albeit while he was living in America).
My head tells me its electricity.
Brian Slater, Patent Law Attorney, New York City
Feminism
Jason Ciment, Business, Los Angeles
we could eliminate feminism on the ground that
its been going on since before this millennium
.......Brian Slater
Antibiotics.
Enrique Aresti-Gutierrez, EEC Attorney, Brussels
the telephone
Lawrence Burian, Attorney, New York City
I did not have time to write anything untill now
and my vote for the 20th century invention, which as was pointed out would
be something which did not exist and was not found in any other way previously.
Even though Solomon stated quite eloquently "There
is nothing new under the sun" which we read this weekend. I admit
the electric guitar is impressive, as is anything electric, but if electricity
was around forever only the harnessing of it was finally formalized. Thus
not an invention. The Atomic Bomb could get a vote, but I would not want
to be so dark, although it is an impressive invention. Toilet Paper gets
my vote
Keith Brooks, IBM-Lotus, London
Most Intriguing Suggestion I've Read so far in
print (Haaretz Magazine): The compass..without it we could never have moved
beyond familiar surroundings to have later created maps so that people
could think about going places.
Ivan Ciment |